研究牙髓炎的研究方法与实验模型的批判性分析
本文为叙述性综述,讨论用于研究牙髓炎的重要实验模型的贡献与不足。体外二维或三维细胞培养及体内动物模型各有局限,现有模型多样性使实验数据向临床外推复杂化,未来需改进设计与标准化。
要点
- 体外二维细胞培养用于解析细菌副产物、促炎细胞因子、成牙本质细胞或牙髓干细胞等关键因子的作用。
- 体内模型可识别牙髓炎关键免疫、血管和神经因子及其在炎症牙髓中的功能与相互作用。
- 现有模型多样性使实验数据向临床情境外推复杂化,未来需改进设计与标准化。
核心结论
- 现有实验模型多样性使实验数据向临床情境外推复杂化,未来需改进模型设计与标准化,例如使用新型分子生物标志物、数据库模型和人工智能。
研究设计与样本
- 叙述性综述,旨在讨论用于研究牙髓炎的最重要实验模型的贡献。
主要发现
- 体外二维细胞培养主要用于解析牙髓炎症关键因子如细菌副产物、促炎细胞因子、成牙本质细胞或牙髓干细胞的特定作用。
- 体外二维细胞培养未重现牙髓组织的三维结构,且除罕见例外未考虑 resident 细胞类型间的相互作用。
- 体外基于组织或器官的模型能更好反映牙髓结构的复杂性,但主要缺点是无法分析血液供应和神经支配的参与。
- 体内模型使研究者能识别牙髓炎关键免疫、血管和神经因子并理解其在炎症牙髓中的功能与相互作用。
- 体内模型的炎症主要由医源性牙本质钻孔伴简单牙髓暴露于口腔环境或短期单个细菌副产物刺激诱导,未反映龋病长期渐进发展。
局限性
- 体外二维细胞培养未重现牙髓组织的三维组织,且除罕见例外未考虑 resident 细胞类型间的相互作用。
- 体外基于组织或器官的模型不允许分析血液供应和神经支配的参与。
- 体内模型的炎症主要由医源性牙本质钻孔伴简单牙髓暴露于口腔环境或短期单个细菌副产物刺激诱导,未反映龋病长期渐进发展。
- 现有模型多样性使实验数据向临床情境外推复杂化。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Pulpitis is the inflammatory response of the dental pulp to a tooth insult, whether it is microbial, chemical, or physical in origin. It is traditionally referred to as reversible or irreversible, a classification for therapeutic purposes that determines the capability of the pulp to heal. Recently, new knowledge about dental pulp physiopathology led to orientate therapeutics towards more frequent preservation of pulp vitality. However, full adoption of these vital pulp therapies by dental practitioners will be achieved only following better understanding of cell and tissue mechanisms involved in pulpitis. The current narrative review aimed to discuss the contribution of the most significant experimental models developed to study pulpitis. Traditionally, in vitro two (2D)- or three (3D)-dimensional cell cultures or in vivo animal models were used to analyse the pulp response to pulpitis inducers at cell, tissue or organ level. In vitro, 2D cell cultures were mainly used to decipher the specific roles of key actors of pulp inflammation such as bacterial by-products, pro-inflammatory cytokines, odontoblasts or pulp stem cells. However, these simple models did not reproduce the 3D organisation of the pulp tissue and, with rare exceptions, did not consider interactions between resident cell types. In vitro, tissue/organ-based models were developed to better reflect the complexity of the pulp structure. Their major disadvantage is that they did not allow the analysis of blood supply and innervation participation. On the contrary, in vivo models have allowed researchers to identify key immune, vascular and nervous actors of pulpitis and to understand their function and interplay in the inflamed pulp. However, inflammation was mainly induced by iatrogenic dentine drilling associated with simple pulp exposure to the oral environment or stimulation by individual bacterial by-products for short periods. Clearly, these models did not reflect the long and progressive development of dental caries. Lastly, the substantial diversity of the existing models makes experimental data extrapolation to the clinical situation complicated. Therefore, improvement in the design and standardisation of future models, for example by using novel molecular biomarkers, databased models and artificial intelligence, will be an essential step in building an incremental knowledge of pulpitis in the future.
引用
- Richert R, Ducret M, Alliot-Licht B, et al. A critical analysis of research methods and experimental models to study pulpitis. Int Endod J. 2022. PMID: 35034368. doi:10.1111/iej.13683
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。