文献速递牙体牙髓病口腔颌面外科

计算机引导显微根尖手术的体外模型研究

[An in vitro model study of computer-guided endodontic microsurgery].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi · 2022-01-01

本研究在6对上下颌牙颌模型上,由新手和经验者分别在自由手、动态导航和静态导板下完成显微根尖手术骨开窗与根尖切除。结果显示动态导航和静态导板可提高新手操作准确性并缩短操作时间,经验者仅角度偏差改善。

要点

  • 新手使用动态导航和静态导板时起点偏差和角度偏差均显著低于自由手。
  • 新手和经验者使用动态导航和静态导板后手术时间均显著短于自由手。
  • 自由手操作时前牙操作时间显著短于后牙,导航下前后牙无显著差异。

核心结论

  • 动态导航和静态导航技术可辅助临床医师特别是新手提高骨开窗与根尖切除显微手术的准确性并缩短操作时间。

研究设计与样本

  • 体外牙颌模型研究,共纳入6对上下颌牙颌模型,固定于仿真人头颅模型上,每个模型上下颌各10个牙位,共120颗牙。
  • 由2位具有不同经验的操作者(新手和经验者)分别在自由手、动态导航和静态导板条件下完成显微根尖手术骨开窗与根尖切除操作,每位操作者每种技术各20颗牙。
  • 术前拍摄锥形束CT模拟手术路径规划,术后拍摄锥形束CT,在导航精度分析软件中比较模拟与实际手术路径在起点、终点和角度的偏差,并记录操作时间。

主要发现

  • 起点偏差新手与经验者间仅在自由手组差异有统计学意义,新手(1.44±0.49)mm vs 经验者(1.02±0.58)mm(q=4.67,P=0.020)。
  • 新手组内,动态导航和静态导板起点偏差(0.76±0.32)和(0.66±0.20)mm均显著低于自由手(q=7.58,P<0.001;q=8.66,P<0.001),角度偏差(5.0°±3.5°、3.9°±2.1°)也均显著低于自由手(10.9°±6.1°)(q=7.38,P<0.001;q=8.70,P<0.001)。
  • 经验者组中,动态导航、静态导板仅在角度偏差(3.6°±1.9°、3.2°±1.7°)上与自由手(8.2°±3.9°)相比差异均有统计学意义(q=5.74,P=0.001;q=6.29,P<0.001)。
  • 新手使用动态导航和静态导板手术时间分别为(4.80±2.15)、(1.09±0.48)min,均显著短于自由手(14.72±6.00)min(q=14.60,P<0.001;q=20.10,P<0.001);经验者使用动态导航和静态导板手术时间分别为(3.40±1.96)、(1.02±0.34)min,均显著短于自由手(7.39±3.33)min(q=5.86,P<0.001;q=9.37,P<0.001)。
  • 自由手组中新手和经验者前牙操作时间均显著短于后牙(q=8.14,P<0.001;q=5.20,P=0.007),而动态导航和静态导板组前后牙操作时间差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05);不同操作者、不同技术对前后牙操作的准确性差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为动态导航和静态导航技术可辅助临床医师特别是新手提高骨开窗与根尖切除显微手术的准确性并缩短操作时间。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: To assess and compare the accuracies and operating time of endodontic microsurgery performed by operators with different levels of experience in endodontics using computer-guided techniques including dynamic and static navigations in a surgical simulation model. Methods: Six pairs of three dimensional (3D)-printed models of upper and lower jaws were set up on dental manikins. A total of 120 teeth (10 teeth each jaw) were included in the models. Microsurgeries of osteotomy and root-resection were performed on the models by two operators with different experience, namely novices and experts, under of free hand (FH)(n=20), dynamic navigation (DN)(n=20), and static navigation (SN)(n=20) conditions, respectively. The duration of each operation was recorded. Cone-beam CT was taken for 3D-printed models before and after the operation. The path of preoperative surgery planning was simulated. The linear deviations at the entry and the end point and the angular deviation of the access path between the simulated and the actual operation were compared by the software. Results: Significant difference of the entry deviation was observed between the novices and the experts in the FH group [(1.44±0.49) and (1.02±0.58) mm] (q=4.67, P=0.020). There were no significant differences between the novices and the experts in the end point and angular deviations (P>0.05). For the novices, the entry deviations in both DN and SN groups [(0.76±0.32) and (0.66±0.20) mm] were significantly lower than those in FH group (q=7.58, P<0.001; q=8.66, P<0.001). The angular deviations in the abovementioned two groups (5.0°±3.5°, 3.9°±2.1°) were significantly lower than that in FH group (10.9°±6.1°) (q=7.38, P<0.001; q=8.70, P<0.001). For the experts, significant differences were found only in the angular deviations among DN, SN and FH groups (3.6°±1.9°, 3.2°±1.7° and 8.2°±3.9°) (q=5.74, P=0.001; q=6.29, P<0.001). The operation durations were significantly shortened for both the novices [(4.80±2.15), (1.09±0.48) min] (q=14.60, P<0.001; q=20.10, P<0.001) and the experts [(3.40±1.96),(1.02±0.34) min] (q=5.86, P<0.001; q=9.37, P<0.001) by using DN and SN techniques. Regarding the differences between tooth types, in FH group, the operating time on the anterior teeth was significantly shorter than that on the posterior teeth (q=8.14, P<0.001; q=5.20, P=0.007), while in DN and SN groups, there were no significant differences in the operating time between two tooth types (P>0.05). No significant differences were discovered in the accuracies on the anterior and posterior teeth among three techniques or between two kinds of operators (P>0.05). Conclusions: Dynamic and static navigation techniques could assist the clinicians, especially the novices, to improve the accuracies and shorten the operating time of osteotomy and root resection microsurgeries. 目的: 研究在体外牙颌模型上具有不同经验的操作者行计算机辅助显微根尖手术的准确性和操作时间。 方法: 本研究共纳入6对上下颌牙颌模型,将其固定于仿真人头颅模型上模拟临床操作,每个模型上下颌各10个牙位,共120颗牙,由2位具有不同经验的操作者(新手和经验者)分别在自由手与导航技术[包括动态导航技术(dynamic navigation,DN)和静态导板技术(static navigation,SN)](每位操作者每种技术各20颗牙)下完成显微根尖手术中骨开窗与根尖切除操作,记录操作时间。术前拍摄牙颌模型锥形束CT,模拟手术路径规划;术后拍摄锥形束CT,在导航精度分析软件中比较模拟与实际手术的路径在测量起点、终点和角度的偏差。 结果: 对于起点偏差,新手与经验者间仅在自由手组中[分别为(1.44±0.49)、(1.02±0.58)mm]差异有统计学意义(q=4.67,P=0.020)。新手和经验者在终点和角度偏差上差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。新手组内,DN和SN亚组的起点偏差[(0.76±0.32)和(0.66±0.20)mm]均显著低于自由手亚组(q=7.58,P<0.001;q=8.66,P<0.001),两亚组的角度偏差(5.0°±3.5°、3.9°±2.1°)也均显著低于自由手亚组(10.9°±6.1°)(q=7.38,P<0.001;q=8.70,P<0.001)。经验者组中,DN、SN亚组仅在角度偏差(3.6°±1.9°、3.2°±1.7°)上与自由手亚组(8.2°±3.9°)相比差异均有统计学意义(q=5.74,P=0.001;q=6.29,P<0.001)。对于手术时间,使用DN和SN后,新手[DN和SN亚组分别为(4.80±2.15)、(1.09±0.48)min](q=14.60,P<0.001;q=20.10,P<0.001)和经验者[DN和SN亚组分别为(3.40±1.96)、(1.02±0.34)min](q=5.86,P<0.001;q=9.37,P<0.001)手术时间均显著短于使用自由手[新手和经验者组分别为(14.72±6.00)、(7.39±3.33)min]。对于不同牙位,新手和经验者使用自由手在前牙的操作时间均显著性少于后牙(q=8.14,P<0.001;q=5.20,P=0.007),而使用DN和SN时前后牙的操作时间差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。不同操作者、使用不同技术对前后牙操作的准确性差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。 结论: 计算机辅助显微根尖手术有助于提高临床医师特别是新手操作的准确性,缩短操作时间。.

来源:Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Chen C, Wang FS, Zhang R, et al. [An in vitro model study of computer-guided endodontic microsurgery]. Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2022. PMID: 35012251. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112144-20210928-00443

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。