Ⅳ期牙周炎患者全牙弓固定修复的疗效:牙支持式与种植支持式的系统综述
本系统综述纳入26项研究(31篇文献),比较Ⅳ期牙周炎患者牙支持式与种植支持式全牙弓固定修复的疗效。无研究采用对照随机设计,偏倚风险高、异质性大。10年预测牙齿丢失1%、种植体丢失4%,修复体失败分别为5%和6%;技术并发症在种植支持式修复体更常见。
要点
- 10年预测牙齿丢失1%、种植体丢失4%,均来自观察性研究的估计。
- 10年修复体丢失牙支持式5%、种植支持式6%,两者相近。
- 技术并发症见于8%牙支持式修复体(7.2年间)和42%种植支持式结构(2.6年间)。
核心结论
- 基于Ⅳ期牙周炎患者全牙弓修复的观察性研究,10年牙齿丢失估计值低于种植体相应估计值。
- 10年时牙支持式与种植支持式修复体的估计丢失相近。
- 与牙支持式修复体相比,种植支持式修复体的技术并发症更常见。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,电子检索CENTRAL/MEDLINE/SCOPUS截至2020年3月,纳入比较或评估Ⅳ期牙周炎患者牙或种植体全牙弓固定修复的随机对照试验及类队列研究。
- 共纳入26项研究(31篇文献),但无研究以对照随机设计回答该科学问题。
- 纳入研究的偏倚风险总体判定为高,Meta分析显示高度异质性。
主要发现
- 牙支持式修复研究的平均加权观察期显著长于种植支持式修复研究。
- 10年预测牙齿丢失为1%,牙支持式全牙弓修复体丢失为5%;15年估计分别为10%和13%。
- 10年预测种植体丢失为4%,种植支持式修复体丢失为6%。
- 技术并发症最常见,影响8%的牙支持式修复体(观察7.2年间)和42%的种植支持式结构(观察2.6年间)。
- 估计9%的种植体出现种植体周围炎或类种植体周围炎症状(3.1年后)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 无研究以对照随机设计回答该科学问题。
- 纳入研究的偏倚风险总体判定为高。
- Meta分析显示高度异质性。
- 牙支持式修复研究的平均加权观察期显著长于种植支持式修复研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the efficacy of implant-supported in comparison to tooth-supported full-arch prostheses in patients with stage IV periodontitis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Systematic electronic search (CENTRAL/MEDLINE/SCOPUS) up to March 2020 was conducted to identify randomized controlled trials and cohort-like studies comparing/evaluating fixed full-arch rehabilitation on teeth or implants in patients with stage IV periodontitis. The primary outcome measure was loss of teeth/implants and restorations. Data extraction was performed to create evidence tables, and meta-analyses were carried out as appropriate. RESULTS: A total of 26 studies (31 publications) were identified but none addressed the scientific question in a controlled and randomized design. The risk of bias throughout the included studies was judged to be high, and meta-analyses demonstrated a high degree of heterogeneity. Mean-weighted observation periods in studies on tooth-supported restorations were significantly longer than in studies on implant-supported restorations. The predicted loss of teeth and tooth-supported full-arch restorations over 10 years was 1% and 5%, respectively. The 15-year estimates were 10% and 13%. Corresponding predictions for implants and implant-supported restorations for 10 years amounted to 4% and 6%, respectively. Technical complications were the most commonly reported and affected 8% of tooth-supported restorations (during 7.2 years) and 42% of implant-supported structures (during 2.6 years). Peri-implantitis- or peri-implantitis-like symptoms were observed at an estimated 9% of implants (after 3.1 years). CONCLUSIONS: Based on observational studies on full-arch rehabilitation of stage IV periodontitis patients, 10-year estimates of tooth loss were lower than the corresponding estimates for implants. Estimated loss of tooth- and implant-supported restorations at 10 years was similar. Technical complications were more prevalent at implant-supported when compared to tooth-supported restorations.
引用
- Tomasi C, Albouy JP, Schaller D, et al. Efficacy of rehabilitation of stage IV periodontitis patients with full-arch fixed prostheses: Tooth-supported versus Implant-supported-A systematic review. J Clin Periodontol. 2021. PMID: 34761430. doi:10.1111/jcpe.13511
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。