局部用氟预防低龄儿童龋:系统综述与网状Meta分析
该系统综述与网状Meta分析纳入24项随访至少1年的随机对照试验,评估专业或自我应用局部用氟预防6岁以下儿童低龄儿童龋的效果。网状Meta分析显示,在8种专业应用氟化物干预中,仅每3个月应用0.9%双氟硅烷(DFS)和每6个月应用5%氟化钠清漆优于对照,且每3个月DFS排名最高,证据确定性极低至中等;自我应用氟化物的证据因研究间异质性而尚无定论。
要点
- 每3个月应用0.9%双氟硅烷(DFS)在预防低龄儿童龋中排名最高,证据确定性极低至中等。
- 每6个月应用5%氟化钠清漆同样优于对照,但排名低于每3个月DFS。
- 自我应用局部用氟的证据因研究间异质性尚无定论。
核心结论
- 在所有被综述的专业应用局部用氟干预中,每3个月应用0.9%双氟硅烷(DFS)的证据确定性为极低至中等,且在预防低龄儿童龋中排名最高。
- 纳入的自我应用局部用氟研究因研究间异质性,证据尚无定论。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与网状Meta分析,纳入随访至少1年的随机对照试验,评估6岁以下儿童中局部用氟的防龋效果。
- 检索8个电子数据库及灰色文献。
- 共纳入24项试验,其中17项评估为高偏倚风险,其余为低偏倚风险;15项评估专业应用氟化物,9项评估自我应用氟化物。
- 10项报告2年随访时净龋增量(dmfs增量)的专业应用氟化物研究纳入网状Meta分析。
- 网状Meta分析采用频率学随机效应模型和累积排名曲线下面积(SUCRA)法排名干预措施,并使用CINeMA框架扩展的GRADE方法评估证据确定性。
主要发现
- 在纳入的8种专业应用氟化物干预中,仅每3个月应用0.9%双氟硅烷(DFS)和每6个月应用5%氟化钠清漆与对照相比能有效预防低龄儿童龋。
- 每3个月应用DFS的排名高于每6个月应用氟化钠清漆。
关键数值与推荐
- 每3个月应用0.9%双氟硅烷(DFS)和每6个月应用5%氟化钠清漆在预防低龄儿童龋方面优于对照。
- 每3个月应用0.9%双氟硅烷(DFS)在预防低龄儿童龋中排名最高,证据确定性为极低至中等。
临床怎么用
- 作者指出,每3个月应用0.9%双氟硅烷(DFS)清漆对预防低龄儿童龋最为有效。
- 本综述建议未来开展高质量研究,比较两种或以上自我应用及专业应用局部用氟干预措施,并具备充分随访。
局限性
- 24项纳入试验中17项评估为高偏倚风险。
- 自我应用局部用氟的纳入研究因研究间异质性,证据尚无定论。
- 专业应用局部用氟干预的证据确定性为极低至中等。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To summarize the evidence on prevention of early childhood caries (ECC) by professionally or self-applied topical fluorides using network meta-analysis. DATA: Randomized-controlled trials with minimum 1-year follow-up assessing caries-preventive effect among children younger than six years. SOURCES: Eight electronic databases and grey literature. STUDY SELECTION: After screening and data extraction, risk of bias assessment using Cochrane risk of bias tool 2.0 was done. Twenty-four trials were included, among which 17 were assessed as "high risk" and remaining as "low risk". Fifteen studies evaluated professionally-applied, and the other nine used self-applied topical fluorides. Ten studies on professionally-applied fluorides reporting the net caries increment (dmfs increment) at 2-years follow-up were included in Network meta-analysis (NMA). NMA and ranking the interventions were conducted using a frequentist random-effects approach and surface under the cumulative ranking command, followed by assessing the certainty of evidence using an extension of GRADE approach with CINeMA framework. Among the eight included interventions of professionally-applied fluorides, only two, i.e., 3-monthly 0.9% difluorosilane (DFS) and 6-monthly 5% sodium fluoride varnish were effective in preventing ECC compared to control with 3-monthly DFS application ranking higher than 6-monthly sodium fluoride varnish application. CONCLUSION: Among all the professionally-applied topical fluoride interventions reviewed, very low to moderate evidence was found with 0.9% DFS application at 3-monthly intervals, which was ranked highest in prevention of ECC. Among the included studies on self-applied topical fluorides, the evidence was inconclusive due to heterogeneity among studies. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: The 0.9% DFS varnish applied every 3 months is most effective for preventing early childhood caries. The review recommends that good quality studies be conducted in future, comparing two or more interventions for both self- as well as professionally-applied topical fluoride agents with adequate follow-up.
引用
- Manchanda S, Sardana D, Liu P, et al. Topical fluoride to prevent early childhood caries: Systematic review with network meta-analysis. J Dent. 2021. PMID: 34780874. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2021.103885
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。