先天性心脏病外科培训课程中融入实操手术训练
本研究将每月院内实操手术训练(HOST)项目纳入本院先天性心脏病外科(CHS)培训课程,通过客观评估方法评价技术技能的提升与保留情况。91%的操作时间平均缩短25%(1:22:00 vs 1:01:21,P<.001)。延迟后复评,47%的学员第3次尝试评分下降4%(94 vs 91,P=.34),但79%的学员第4次尝试评分提高(91 vs 99,P=.004),恢复至先前水平。
要点
- HOST课程融入CHS培训课程,采用客观评估测量技术表现。
- 学员两次尝试间评分平均提高13%,操作时间平均缩短25%。
- 延迟后复评,技能得以保留,第4次尝试评分恢复至先前水平。
核心结论
- 每月HOST课程成功融入CHS外科医生培训课程,使用客观评估测量技术表现。
- 学员在所有评估操作中均表现出提升,并在延迟后复评时保留了技能,凸显其在CHS培训中的价值。
研究设计与样本
- 带教老师在模型上演示操作,每名学员随后进行2次尝试,并录制用于客观评估。
- 课程完成后,学员在延迟后对4个操作额外重复2次以评估技能保留。
主要发现
- 91%的操作时间平均缩短25%(第1次尝试1:22:00,第2次尝试1:01:21;P<.001)。
- 在单个操作分析中,7个操作中有3个仍具有统计学显著性(P<.05)。
- 延迟2-14个月后对4个操作评估技能保留,47%的学员第3次尝试评分下降4%(第2次尝试94,第3次尝试91;P=.34),但79%的学员第4次尝试评分提高(第3次尝试91,第4次尝试99;P=.004),与先前表现相当。
临床怎么用
- 可将每月HOST课程与3D打印心脏模型结合,纳入先天性心脏病外科培训课程。
- 采用客观评估方法(如HOST-CHS评分和操作时间)监测学员技术技能的提升与保留。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The monthly in-house Hands-On Surgical Training (HOST) program was incorporated into the congenital heart surgery (CHS) curriculum for surgical trainees within our institution. This study evaluated whether there was an improvement and retention of technical skills throughout the curriculum via objective assessment methods. METHODS: Twelve 3-dimensional-printed surgical heart models were included into the year-long curriculum. The monthly sessions were attended by all trainees and staff surgeons. Proctors demonstrated the operation on a model, which was followed by 2 attempts by each trainee. Attempts were recorded for objective assessment. On completion of the curriculum trainees repeated 4 procedures an additional 2 times after a delay to assess skill retention. RESULTS: Twelve sessions were completed by 7 trainees within the curriculum. Objective assessments were performed in 7 sessions. Eighty-one percent of trainees' scores improved between the 2 attempts, with a mean improvement of 13% (attempt 1: HOST-CHS score of 79, attempt 2: HOST-CHS score of 89; P < .001). Similarly, 91% of procedural times improved by a mean of 25% (attempt 1, 1:22:00 [hours:minutes:seconds]; attempt 2, 1:01:21; P < .001). During individual procedure analysis, statistical significance remained in 3 of 7 procedures (P < .05). Four procedures were assessed for skill retention after a delay (2-14 months). Scores decreased by 4% in 47% of trainees during attempt 3 (attempt 2: HOST-CHS score of 94, attempt 3: HOST-CHS score of 91; P = .34) but improved in 79% during attempt 4 (attempt 3: HOST-CHS score of 91, attempt 4: HOST-CHS score of 99; P = .004), matching their previous performance. CONCLUSIONS: The monthly HOST course was successfully incorporated into a training curriculum for CHS surgeons using objective assessments to measure technical performance. Trainees demonstrated an improvement across all evaluated procedures and retained their skills when reassessed after a delay highlighting its value in CHS training.
引用
- Hussein N, Honjo O, Barron DJ, et al. The Incorporation of Hands-On Surgical Training in a Congenital Heart Surgery Training Curriculum. Ann Thorac Surg. 2020. PMID: 33307072. doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2020.11.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。