六种肺切除术后短期死亡预测模型的外部验证
本研究在6600例2012至2018年间接受肺切除的患者中外部验证了六种预测术后死亡的多变量模型。结果显示模型AUC为0.67至0.73,五种模型校准不足且高估死亡,改良Eurolung模型统计表现尚可但缺乏临床有效性,无模型能充分预测90天死亡。
要点
- 五种模型校准不佳且区分度不足,死亡风险被显著高估。
- 改良Eurolung模型统计表现 adequate 但临床有效性不足。
- 现有模型均不能充分预测肺切除术后90天死亡。
核心结论
- 五种验证模型校准差且区分度不足,改良Eurolung模型统计表现 adequate 但缺乏临床有效性。
- 需要开发能准确估计当代肺切除风险的模型。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心队列外部验证研究,纳入6600例2012至2018年间接受肺切除的患者。
- 验证Thoracoscore、改良Thoracoscore、Eurolung、改良Eurolung、欧洲社会客观评分和Brunelli六种模型。
主要发现
- 平均年龄66.8岁(±10.9岁),男性占49.7%(n=3281)。
- 院内、30天、围手术期和90天死亡率分别为1.5%(n=99)、1.4%(n=93)、1.8%(n=121)和3.1%(n=204)。
- 模型AUC范围为0.67至0.73。
- 五种模型校准不充分,五种模型显著高估死亡。
- 无模型能充分预测90天死亡。
关键数值与推荐
- 模型区分度以AUC评估,范围为0.67至0.73。
- 校准评估包括校准截距、校准斜率、观测与期望比和校准图。
临床怎么用
- 现有模型预测肺切除术后短期死亡准确性不足,临床使用需谨慎。
- 改良Eurolung模型统计表现尚可但临床有效性不足,不宜常规依赖。
局限性
- 未报告模型开发人群与验证队列的详细差异。
- 未报告各模型具体校准指标数值。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: National guidelines advocate the use of clinical prediction models to estimate perioperative mortality for patients undergoing lung resection. Several models have been developed that may potentially be useful but contemporary external validation studies are lacking. The aim of this study was to validate existing models in a multicentre patient cohort. METHODS: The Thoracoscore, Modified Thoracoscore, Eurolung, Modified Eurolung, European Society Objective Score and Brunelli models were validated using a database of 6600 patients who underwent lung resection between 2012 and 2018. Models were validated for in-hospital or 30-day mortality (depending on intended outcome of each model) and also for 90-day mortality. Model calibration (calibration intercept, calibration slope, observed to expected ratio and calibration plots) and discrimination (area under receiver operating characteristic curve) were assessed as measures of model performance. RESULTS: Mean age was 66.8 years (±10.9 years) and 49.7% (n = 3281) of patients were male. In-hospital, 30-day, perioperative (in-hospital or 30-day) and 90-day mortality were 1.5% (n = 99), 1.4% (n = 93), 1.8% (n = 121) and 3.1% (n = 204), respectively. Model area under the receiver operating characteristic curves ranged from 0.67 to 0.73. Calibration was inadequate in five models and mortality was significantly overestimated in five models. No model was able to adequately predict 90-day mortality. CONCLUSIONS: Five of the validated models were poorly calibrated and had inadequate discriminatory ability. The modified Eurolung model demonstrated adequate statistical performance but lacked clinical validity. Development of accurate models that can be used to estimate the contemporary risk of lung resection is required.
引用
- Taylor M, Szafron B, Martin GP, et al. External validation of six existing multivariable clinical prediction models for short-term mortality in patients undergoing lung resection. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2021. PMID: 33230562. doi:10.1093/ejcts/ezaa422
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。