三维打印心脏模型模拟Norwood手术的评估工具验证与技术提升
本研究利用三维打印的左心发育不良综合征心脏模型模拟两种Norwood手术,验证了手术特异性评估工具Hands-On Surgical Training-CHS的可靠性,并发现无论有无督导在场,反复演练均可提升技术表现。
要点
- 手术特异性评估工具可由非专家评分者可靠使用。
- 有经验与初级外科医生评分区分明显(P ≤ 0.001)。
- 演练(有督导或独立)均能提升技术评分与操作时间。
核心结论
- 手术特异性评估工具可用于复杂先天性心脏病手术模拟的技术表现评估,且非专家评分者亦能可靠评分。
- 有督导和独立演练均能提升技术技能,支持其在先天性心脏病外科培训中的价值。
研究设计与样本
- 在三维打印的左心发育不良综合征心脏模型上模拟两种Norwood手术。
- 5名有经验外科医生与5名初级外科医生完成操作,由10名先天性心脏病手术经验不同的评分者回顾性评估。
- 验证后30名外科医生(24名有督导指导,6名仅用培训视频与客观反馈)各模拟Norwood手术两次。
主要发现
- 有经验外科医生的表现评分持续更高,评分者能清晰区分有经验与初级外科医生(P ≤ 0.001)。
- Hands-On Surgical Training-CHS工具在所有评分者中显示高评分者间信度(0.86)与评分者内信度(0.80)。
- 有经验与初级外科医生评分在所有评分者间高度一致,无统计学显著差异(P = 0.50)。
关键数值与推荐
- 评分者间信度0.86,评分者内信度0.80。
- 有经验与初级外科医生区分P ≤ 0.001,评分者间一致性P = 0.50。
- 两次尝试评分提升9%、时间提升15%(P ≤ 0.001);非督导亚组总分提升15%(P = 0.002)。
临床怎么用
- 可将手术特异性评估工具用于复杂先天性心脏病手术模拟培训的技术表现评价。
- 非专家评分者经工具辅助可提供可靠评估,便于培训项目推广。
- 鼓励在有督导或独立条件下反复演练以提升技术技能。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The hands-on surgical training course utilizes 3-dimensional (3D)-printed heart models to simulate complex congenital heart operations. This study aimed to validate a model and assessment tool in the simulation of 2 techniques of the Norwood operation and investigate whether technical performance improves following rehearsal with or without proctor presence. METHODS: Five 'experienced' and 5 'junior' surgeons performed 2 techniques of the Norwood operation on 3D-printed models of hypoplastic left heart syndrome. Performances were retrospectively assessed by 10 raters with varying experience in congenital heart surgery (CHS) (Medical Doctorate versus non-Medical Doctorate). Assessments were made with the procedure-specific Hands-On Surgical Training-CHS tool. Results were analysed for technical performance and rater consistency. Following validation, 30 surgeons (24 with proctor guidance and 6 with training videos and objective feedback only) simulated the Norwood operation twice. RESULTS: Performance scores were consistently higher for experienced surgeons and raters discriminated clearly between the experienced and junior surgeons (P ≤ 0.001). The hands-on surgical training-CHS tool showed high inter-rater (0.86) and intra-rater (0.80) reliability among all raters. Scores for both experienced and junior surgeons were highly consistent across all raters, with no statistically significant difference (P = 0.50). All surgeons successfully performed the Norwood operation. Sixty attempts were scored in total. Eighty-seven percentage (26/30) of surgeons' scores (mean: attempt 1 = 92, attempt 2 = 104) and times [mean: attempt 1 = 1:22:00, attempt 2 = 1:08:00 (h:mm:ss)] improved between the 2 attempts by 9% and 15% respectively (P ≤ 0.001). Total scores of all surgeons in the non-proctored subgroup (6) improved by 15% on average (mean: attempt 1 = 86, attempt 2 = 105, P = 0.002). CONCLUSIONS: Procedure-specific assessment tools can be developed to evaluate technical performance for complex CHS simulation and be performed reliably by non-expert raters. Rehearsal both under supervision and independently leads to technical skill improvement further supporting its value in CHS training.
引用
- Hussein N, Honjo O, Barron DJ, et al. Assessment tool validation and technical skill improvement in the simulation of the Norwood operation using three-dimensional-printed heart models. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2020. PMID: 33249480. doi:10.1093/ejcts/ezaa321
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。