文献速递先天性心脏病外科心外重症与机械循环支持

斯坦福急性心力衰竭症状评分用于住院心力衰竭患儿

The Stanford acute heart failure symptom score for patients hospitalized with heart failure.
PubMed 文献 · J Heart Lung Transplant · 2020-08-08

斯坦福儿科心衰医生开发了一种基于呼吸困难、喂养困难和活动受限三个症状域的急性心衰评分(HFS),每域0-4分,总分0-12分。在12例同时评分的住院患儿中组内相关系数为0.94,28例患儿中峰值评分四分位与住院时长和院内死亡率相关(p<0.01)。该评分可能有助于量化监测住院急性失代偿心衰患儿的每日症状。

要点

  • HFS包含呼吸、喂养、活动三个症状域,每域0-4分,总分0-12分。
  • 评分者间信度优秀,总体ICC为0.94(呼吸0.89、喂养0.85、活动0.80)。
  • 峰值评分四分位与住院时长和院内死亡率相关(p<0.01)。

核心结论

  • 这种简单的急性HFS可能有助于量化并监测住院急性失代偿心衰患儿的每日心衰症状,不受病因或年龄组限制。
  • 评分在不同级别医生间具有优秀的评分者间信度,且与主要住院结局相关,支持其临床有效性。
  • 需要在多中心队列中进一步验证。

研究设计与样本

  • 斯坦福儿科心衰医生回顾现有HFS的局限性后,开发了对应心衰三大核心症状(呼吸困难、喂养困难、活动受限)的急性HFS。
  • 评分经3年试点阶段迭代改进至不再修改,最终版用于评估不同级别医生间的评分者间信度。
  • 回顾分析2019年7月至10月所有儿科心衰出院患者的峰值HFS与死亡和住院时长的关系(N=28)。

主要发现

  • 最终HFS为3个症状域各4分有序严重程度评分,总分0-12分。
  • 12例住院急性失代偿心衰患儿同时评分时,总体ICC为0.94(呼吸ICC=0.89、喂养ICC=0.85、活动ICC=0.80)。
  • 评分轨迹反映临床对患者心衰治疗反应的印象,涵盖单心室和双心室心脏病以及射血分数降低或保留的心衰综合征。
  • 28例住院患儿中,峰值评分四分位与住院时长(p<0.01)和院内死亡率(p<0.01)相关。
  • HFS 0-3分中位住院时长5天、死亡率0%;HFS 4-6分中位18天、死亡率0%;HFS 5-9分中位29天、死亡率23%;HFS 10-12分中位121天、死亡率50%。

关键数值与推荐

  • HFS总分0-12分,由呼吸、喂养、活动3个症状域各0-4分组成。
  • 总体ICC为0.94,呼吸ICC=0.89、喂养ICC=0.85、活动ICC=0.80。
  • HFS 0-3分:中位住院时长5天,死亡率0%。
  • HFS 4-6分:中位住院时长18天,死亡率0%。
  • HFS 5-9分:中位住院时长29天,死亡率23%;HFS 10-12分:中位住院时长121天,死亡率50%。

临床怎么用

  • 可用于住院急性失代偿心衰患儿每日症状的量化与监测,不受病因或年龄组限制。
  • 评分由不同级别医生完成时具有高度一致性,适合作为临床工具和临床试验终点。
  • 峰值评分较高者住院时长和死亡风险更高,可辅助识别需密切关注的患儿。

局限性

  • 单中心研究,样本量较小(N=28)。
  • 需要在多中心队列中进一步验证。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Currently, there are no simple tools to evaluate the acute heart failure (HF) symptom severity in children hospitalized with acute decompensated HF (ADHF). We sought to develop an inpatient HF score (HFS) that could be used as a clinical tool and for clinical trials. METHODS: Pediatric HF clinicians at Stanford reviewed the limitations of existing HFSs, which include lack of calibration to the inpatient setting, omission of gastrointestinal symptoms, need for multiple age-based tools, and scores that prioritize treatment intensity over patient symptoms. To address these, we developed an acute HFS corresponding to the 3 cardinal symptoms of HF: difficulty with breathing, feeding, and activity. The score was iteratively improved over a 3-year pilot phase until no further changes were made. The inter-rater reliability (IRR) across a range of providers was assessed using the final version. Peak HFSs were analyzed against mortality and length of stay (LOS) for all pediatric HF discharges between July and October 2019. RESULTS: The final HFS was a 4-point ordinal severity score for each of the 3 symptom domains (total score 0-12). Among clinicians who scored 12 inpatients with ADHF simultaneously, the intraclass correlation (ICC) was 0.94 (respiratory ICC = 0.89, feeding ICC = 0.85, and activity ICC = 0.80). Score trajectory reflected our clinical impression of patient response to HF therapies across a range of HF syndromes including 1- and 2-ventricle heart disease and reduced or preserved ejection fraction. Among the 28 patients hospitalized during a 3-months period (N = 28), quartiles of peak score were associated with LOS (p < 0.01) and in-hospital mortality (p < 0.01): HFS 0 to 3 (median LOS of 5 days and mortality of 0%), HFS 4 to 6 (median LOS of 18 days and mortality of 0%), HFS 5 to 9 (median LOS of 29 days and mortality of 23%), and HFS 10 to 12 (median LOS of 121 days and mortality of 50%). CONCLUSION: This simple acute HFS may be a useful tool to quantify and monitor day-to-day HF symptoms in children hospitalized with ADHF regardless of etiology or age group. The score has excellent IRR across provider levels and is associated with major hospital outcomes supporting its clinical validity. Validation in a multicenter cohort is warranted.

来源:J Heart Lung Transplant,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Almond CS, Chen S, Dykes JC, et al. The Stanford acute heart failure symptom score for patients hospitalized with heart failure. J Heart Lung Transplant. 2020. PMID: 33032871. doi:10.1016/j.healun.2020.08.002

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。