先天性心脏病手术操作特异性评估工具的开发与验证
本研究针对先天性心脏病手术(CHS)中动手模拟训练缺乏客观评估方法的问题,开发并验证了用于3D打印模型上动脉调转术的操作特异性评估工具HOST-CHS。5名专家和5名初级外科医生在两次培训课程中完成手术,由9名不同经验评估者回顾性评分。结果显示HOST-CHS的组间和组内信度高于全局评定量表(GRS),专家总分在所有评估者间高度一致,且所有级别评估者均能区分初级与专家外科医生。
要点
- HOST-CHS评估工具在动脉调转术模拟中显示出高于GRS的组间和组内信度。
- 专家外科医生的总分在所有评估者间高度一致。
- 所有级别评估者均能区分初级与专家外科医生的表现。
核心结论
- HOST-CHS是用于动脉调转术模拟的客观操作特异性评估工具,在不同经验评估者间具有一致性。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入5名专家和5名初级外科医生,在两次动手手术培训课程中于3D打印模型上完成动脉调转术,由9名不同经验评估者(staff surgeons、resident surgeons、non-MD raters)回顾性评估。
主要发现
- HOST-CHS工具的组间和组内信度高于GRS。
- 专家外科医生的总分在所有评估者间高度一致。
- 非医学博士评估者对初级外科医生的总分略高于住院医师和staff评估者。
- 所有级别评估者均能区分初级与专家外科医生。
临床怎么用
- 该工具可用于量化并准确评估动脉调转术模拟操作表现,支持先天性心脏病外科医生的培训与培养。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Hands-on surgical simulation has been sought to address training limitations within congenital heart surgery (CHS). However, there is a need for objective assessment methods to measure surgeons' performance to justify its global adoption. This study aimed to validate a procedure-specific assessment tool for the simulation of the arterial switch operation on 3D-printed models and to evaluate the consistency of scoring among evaluators with different levels of experience in CHS. METHODS: Five "expert" and 5 "junior" surgeons performed the arterial switch procedure on 3D-printed models with transposition of the great arteries during 2 hands-on surgical training courses. Their performance was retrospectively assessed by 9 evaluators with varying experience in CHS (staff surgeons, resident surgeons, and non-MD raters). Assessments were done using 2 assessment tools: the Hands-On Surgical Training-Congenital Heart Surgery (HOST-CHS) assessment tool and the global rating scale (GRS). RESULTS: The HOST-CHS tool showed a higher interrater and intrarater reliability compared with the GRS. Total scores for expert surgeons were highly consistent across all evaluators. Non-MD raters' total scores for junior surgeons were slightly higher than those of residents and staff evaluators. All grades of evaluator were able to discriminate between junior and expert surgeons. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates the development and validation of an objective, procedure-specific assessment tool for the arterial switch operation with consistency among evaluators with different experience. There is now a platform for quantifying and accurately evaluating performance, which will be highly beneficial in training and developing the next generation of congenital heart surgeons.
引用
- Hussein N, Lim A, Honjo O, et al. Development and validation of a procedure-specific assessment tool for hands-on surgical training in congenital heart surgery. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2019. PMID: 31973896. doi:10.1016/j.jtcvs.2019.11.130
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。