STS数据库二尖瓣疾病分类错误与修复率评估
本研究回顾性审查单中心1年内314例孤立二尖瓣手术的原始记录和超声心动图,由经验丰富的外科医生、超声核心实验室和数据管理员重新判定病因。结果显示31.5%的患者病因分类被改变,原发性MR的真实修复率由数据库报告的87.1%升至93.2%,提示STS数据库后验病历摘录方法存在显著分类偏差。
要点
- STS数据库后验摘录导致31.5%的二尖瓣病因分类错误
- 原发性MR真实修复率93.2%高于数据库报告的87.1%
- 需更详细的数据录入方法以准确报告病因和修复率
核心结论
- 原始记录和影像审查显示二尖瓣手术病因分类与后验病历摘录方法存在显著不一致。
- 需要更详细的数据录入方法以准确报告原发性MR的真实病因和修复率。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性审查单医疗系统1年内所有孤立二尖瓣手术的原始记录和超声心动图。
- 由经验丰富的二尖瓣外科医生、超声核心实验室和数据管理员共同判定病因并与数据库录入数据比较。
主要发现
- 共纳入314例孤立二尖瓣手术,数据库原分类:原发性163例(52%)、继发性22例(7%)、风湿性37例(12%)、感染性心内膜炎24例(8%)、其他33例(10%)、未知35例(11%)。
- 审查后病因判定:原发性177例(56%)、继发性33例(11%)、风湿性61例(20%)、感染性心内膜炎25例(8%)、其他18例(5%)。
- 314例中99例(31.5%)病因分类发生改变。
- 数据库报告原发性MR修复率为142/163(87.1%),审查后真实修复率为165/177(93.2%)。
临床怎么用
- 心胸外科智能体应意识到STS数据库病因分类可能存在显著错误,质控评估时需结合原始记录和影像核实。
- 报告原发性MR修复率时应考虑数据摘录方法对真实修复率的影响。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性内容。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Surgical repair of primary mitral regurgitation (MR) is considered an indicator of quality performance. Therefore, accurate data reporting is critical for quality assessment. During an institutional quality review, MR etiology could not be determined in 40% of operations in The Society of Thoracic Surgeons database entries, and therefore our true repair rate could not be reliably ascertained. Therefore, we reviewed all source documents and echocardiograms to assess our true disease etiology and repair rate. METHODS: Source records and echocardiograms of all operations performed in a single health care system for a 1-year period were reviewed by an experienced mitral valve surgeon, an echocardiographic core laboratory, and a data manager. Disease etiology and operation were compared with data previously entered in the database by post hoc chart abstraction. RESULTS: In all, 314 isolated mitral valve operations were performed. The MR was originally classified as primary, 163 (52%); secondary, 22 (7%); rheumatic, 37 (12%); endocarditis, 24 (8%); other, 33 (10%); and unknown, 35 (11%). Reported repair rate for primary MR was 142 of 163 (87.1%). After review, etiology was determined to be primary, 177 (56%); secondary, 33 (11%); rheumatic, 61 (20%); endocarditis, 25 (8%); and others, 18 (5%)-resulting in a change of classification in 99 of 314 patients (31.5%) and a true repair rate for primary MR of 165 of 177 (93.2%). CONCLUSIONS: Source document and imaging review of mitral valve surgery revealed significant discordance with post hoc chart abstraction methods. A more detailed data entry methodology is necessary to accurately report the true disease etiology and repair rates for primary MR.
引用
- Hamandi M, Ryan WH, Grayburn PA, et al. Misclassification of Mitral Valve Disease and Rate of Surgical Repair in The Society of Thoracic Surgeons Database. Ann Thorac Surg. 2020. PMID: 31962113. doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2019.11.047
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。