采用基准标准评估微创食管切除术的转型
该研究基于2007至2017年前瞻性数据库383例食管切除术患者,比较微创与开放食管切除术,采用ECCG标准化并发症定义评估。结果显示MIE组并发症频率、严重程度和复杂性更优,且不损害手术结局,推荐MIE可作为食管癌手术标准方法,转型应参照国际基准。
要点
- MIE组并发症频率、Clavien-Dindo严重程度和综合并发症指数均优于OE组。
- MIE与OE在肺炎、ICU再入院、房颤和吻合口漏分级上无显著差异。
- MIE可成为食管癌手术管理的标准方法,转型应参照国际基准。
核心结论
- MIE组并发症频率、严重程度和复杂性优于OE组,且不损害手术结局。
- MIE可成为食管癌手术管理的标准方法,转型应参照国际基准。
研究设计与样本
- 2007至2017年前瞻性数据库纳入383例食管切除术患者,MIE占49.6%。
- 并发症按ECCG定义,用Clavien-Dindo分级和综合并发症指数评估。
主要发现
- 383例中299例(76%)为男性,中位年龄64.5岁(范围56-72岁)。
- MIE组胸部吻合更常见(156/190,82.1%),OE组为113/193,58.5%(P=.001)。
- 肺炎MIE 19.5% vs OE 26.9%(P=.09),ICU再入院7.4% vs 9.3%(P=.519),房颤11.1% vs 6.7%(P=.082),吻合口漏分级P=.99。
- 年龄、组织学(P=.222)、pT分期(P=.136)、淋巴结阳性(P=.918)无差异;3期癌OE 42.0%,MIE 47.9%。
关键数值与推荐
- MIE组并发症频率、Clavien-Dindo严重程度和综合并发症指数均优于OE组。
- MIE与OE在个体并发症分组或分级上无显著差异。
临床怎么用
- MIE可作为食管癌手术管理的标准方法。
- 每位外科医生开展该技术时应参照国际标准进行基准评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Minimally invasive esophagectomy (MIE) is performed in nearly 50% of patients worldwide. The effectiveness of the technique arises from a single randomized control trial and multiple single series cohorts. Consistent reporting of complications is varied. We describe our experience of transitioning to MIE compared with open esophagectomy (OE) with the use of Esophageal Complications Consensus Group (ECCG) standardized complication benchmark definitions. METHODS: Between 2007 and 2017, all patients undergoing esophagectomy were identified with the use of a prospectively curated database. Complications were defined by the ECCG and graded with the Clavien-Dindo (most severe complication) and comprehensive complication index (complexity of complications during hospital stay). RESULTS: Of 383 patients, 299 (76%) were men with a median age of 64.5 years (range, 56-72 years). MIE was performed in 49.6%. No differences were found in age, histologic finding (P = .222), pT stage (P = .136), or nodal positivity (P = .918). Stage 3 cancers accounted for 42.0% of OEs and 47.9% of MIEs. A thoracic anastomosis was more frequent in MIEs (156 of 190; 82.1%) than in OEs (113 of 193; 58.5%; P = .001). Frequency, severity (Clavien-Dindo), and complexity (comprehensive complication index) of complications were better in the MIE group, without compromising operative outcomes. No differences were identified in individual complication groupings or grade in MIEs compared with OEs (pneumonia: 19.5% versus 26.9% ([P = .09]; intensive care unit readmission: 7.4% versus 9.3% [P = .519]; atrial fibrillation: 11.1% versus 6.7% [P = .082], or grade of leak [P = .99]). CONCLUSIONS: These results compare favorably to those reported by ECCG. MIE can be the standard approach for surgical management of esophageal cancer. Introduction of the approach in each surgeon's practice should be benchmarked to international standards.
引用
- Carroll PA, Jacob N, Yeung JC, et al. Using Benchmarking Standards to Evaluate Transition to Minimally Invasive Esophagectomy. Ann Thorac Surg. 2019. PMID: 31541632. doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2019.08.019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。