按患者个体风险分层的诊疗阶段死亡分析
该研究对2012至2018年期间接受孤立冠状动脉旁路移植术、孤立瓣膜手术及CABG联合单瓣膜手术的患者实施诊疗阶段死亡分析(POCMA),将死亡触发因素按术前、术中、ICU、术后病房和出院阶段分类,并按STS风险评分分层。结果显示死亡呈双峰分布,低风险和高风险患者分别占37.3%和38.8%;低风险患者死亡触发多发生在术后ICU阶段,高风险患者则多发生在术前阶段。
要点
- 死亡触发因素分布:术前49.3%、术中13.4%、ICU 23.9%、术后病房3.0%、出院10.4%。
- 低风险患者死亡触发主要在术后ICU阶段,高风险患者主要在术前阶段。
- 按患者风险分层聚焦特定诊疗阶段可改善质量和结局。
核心结论
- 死亡按患者风险谱呈双峰分布,低风险和高风险患者各占约三分之一以上。
- 低风险患者死亡触发多发生在术后ICU阶段,高风险患者多发生在术前阶段。
- 根据患者风险谱聚焦特定诊疗阶段是改善质量和结局的机会。
研究设计与样本
- 对2012至2018年接受孤立CABG、孤立瓣膜手术及CABG联合单瓣膜手术且具备STS风险模型的患者实施POCMA。
- 共纳入3919例孤立CABG、901例孤立瓣膜和321例CABG联合单瓣膜手术,总体粗死亡率4.6%,STS风险评分中位数5.8%。
- 对67例死亡患者进行POCMA,按STS风险评分分层为低风险(<4%)、中风险(4%至8%)和高风险(>8%)。
主要发现
- 死亡触发因素分布:术前49.3%、术中13.4%、ICU 23.9%、术后病房3.0%、出院10.4%。
- 死亡分布呈双峰,低风险患者占37.3%,高风险患者占38.8%。
- 低风险患者死亡触发最常见于术后ICU阶段,高风险患者最常见于术前阶段。
临床怎么用
- 对低风险患者应加强术后ICU阶段的监测和干预。
- 对高风险患者应优化术前评估和管理以降低死亡风险。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Phase of care mortality analysis (POCMA) is a quality improvement tool categorizing triggers for mortality into phases of patient care. However, the relationship between a patient's risk profile and the triggers for mortality is incompletely understood. METHODS: POCMA was implemented for cases with available Society of Thoracic Surgeons (STS) risk models. Risk-adjusted rates were obtained from the STS database. Mortality triggers were categorized by the phase of occurrence (preoperative, intraoperative, intensive care unit [ICU], postoperative floor, and discharge). Patients were then stratified by STS risk score: low risk (<4%), intermediate (4% to 8%), and high risk (>8%). RESULTS: A total of 3,919 isolated coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG), 901 isolated valve, and 321 CABG plus single-valve procedures were performed from 2012 to 2018, with 4.6% crude mortality and a median STS risk score of 5.8%. POCMA was performed on 67 patient mortalities, with triggers occurring in the following phases of care: 49.3% preoperative, 13.4% intraoperative, 23.9% ICU, 3.0% postoperative floor, and 10.4% discharge phase. Mortality distribution was bimodal, occurring mostly in low-risk (37.3%) and high-risk (38.8%) patients. For low-risk patients, the trigger for mortality most frequently occurred during the postoperative ICU phase, while for high-risk patients, the trigger for mortality most frequently occurred during the preoperative phase. CONCLUSIONS: Mortality had a bimodal distribution with respect to patient risk profile. Phase-of-care triggers for mortality differed according to patient risk profile: low-risk triggers during the postoperative ICU phase versus high-risk triggers typically during the preoperative phase. Specific focus on phases according to the patient's risk profile represents an opportunity to improve quality and outcomes.
引用
- Umana-Pizano JB, Nissen AP, Nguyen S, et al. Phase of Care Mortality Analysis According to Individual Patient Risk Profile. Ann Thorac Surg. 2019. PMID: 30836097. doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2019.01.057
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。