马萨诸塞州心脏手术结果强制公开报告:2003至2014年经验
该研究分析2003至2014年马萨诸塞州39,400例与全国1,815,234例孤立冠状动脉旁路移植术数据,比较风险因素、预期和观察死亡率。马萨诸塞州风险标准化死亡率持续显著低于全国,预期死亡率2008年后与全国无差异,风险规避证据不一致。
要点
- 马萨诸塞州CABG风险标准化死亡率持续显著低于全国。
- 马萨诸塞州患者糖尿病、外周血管病等风险因素几率更高。
- 强制公开报告下风险规避证据不一致且无定论。
核心结论
- 12年强制公开报告期间,马萨诸塞州风险标准化CABG死亡率持续显著低于全国。
- 马萨诸塞州预期死亡率与全国相当或更高,风险规避证据矛盾且无定论。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2003至2014年马萨诸塞州STS数据(N=39,400例)和全国STS数据(N=1,815,234例)的孤立CABG病例。
- 比较风险因素患病率、预期死亡率(STS预测手术死亡风险)、观察死亡率和风险标准化死亡率。
主要发现
- 马萨诸塞州患者糖尿病、外周血管病、低射血分数和年龄≥75岁的几率显著高于全国。
- 马萨诸塞州患者休克(OR 0.66,99%CI 0.53-0.83)、急诊(OR 0.57,99%CI 0.52-0.61)、再次手术、慢性肺病、透析、肥胖和女性的几率更低。
- STS预测手术死亡风险在马萨诸塞州2003至2007年高于全国(P<.001),2008至2014年无差异(P=.135)。
- 调整STS预测风险后,马萨诸塞州患者30天死亡几率显著低于全国(OR 0.79,99%CI 0.66-0.96)。
- 异常值项目对预期死亡率和CABG病例份额的影响不一致且短暂。
临床怎么用
- 强制公开报告未显示对高风险患者手术可及性的明确负面影响。
- 需持续监测风险调整模型以评估公开报告对临床决策的潜在影响。
局限性
- 观察性设计无法确立因果关系。
- 风险规避证据不一致且无定论。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Beginning in 2002, all 14 Massachusetts nonfederal cardiac surgery programs submitted Society of Thoracic Surgeons (STS) National Database data to the Massachusetts Data Analysis Center for mandatory state-based analysis and reporting, and to STS for nationally benchmarked analyses. We sought to determine whether longitudinal prevalences and trends in risk factors and observed and expected mortality differed between Massachusetts and the nation. METHODS: We analyzed 2003 to 2014 expected (STS predicted risk of operative [in-hospital + 30-day] mortality), observed, and risk-standardized isolated coronary artery bypass graft mortality using Massachusetts STS data (N = 39,400 cases) and national STS data (N = 1,815,234 cases). Analyses included percentage shares of total Massachusetts coronary artery bypass graft volume and expected mortality rates of 2 hospitals before and after outlier designation. RESULTS: Massachusetts patients had significantly higher odds of diabetes, peripheral vascular disease, low ejection fraction, and age ≥75 years relative to national data and lower odds of shock (odds ratio, 0.66; 99% confidence interval, 0.53-0.83), emergency (odds ratio, 0.57, 99% confidence interval, 0.52-0.61), reoperation, chronic lung disease, dialysis, obesity, and female sex. STS predicted risk of operative [in-hospital + 30-day] mortality for Massachusetts patients was higher than national rates during 2003 to 2007 (P < .001) and no different during 2008 to 2014 (P = .135). Adjusting for STS predicted risk of operative [in-hospital + 30-day] mortality, Massachusetts patients had significantly lower odds (odds ratio, 0.79; 99% confidence interval, 0.66-0.96) of 30-day mortality relative to national data. Outlier programs experienced inconsistent, transient influences on expected mortality and their percentage shares of Massachusetts coronary artery bypass graft cases. CONCLUSIONS: During 12 years of mandatory public reporting, Massachusetts risk-standardized coronary artery bypass graft mortality was consistently and significantly lower than national rates, expected rates were comparable or higher, and evidence for risk aversion was conflicting and inconclusive.
引用
- Shahian DM, Torchiana DF, Engelman DT, et al. Mandatory public reporting of cardiac surgery outcomes: The 2003 to 2014 Massachusetts experience. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2018. PMID: 30772041. doi:10.1016/j.jtcvs.2018.12.072
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。