婴儿心脏手术后早期拔管实践的可持续性:PHN CLS 研究后续随访
儿科心脏网络协作学习研究(PHN CLS)曾成功在四家医院提高婴儿心脏术后6小时内早期拔管率。本研究将PHN CLS数据与儿科心脏重症监护联盟登记处链接,比较研究期(临床实践指南后)与研究完成后第一年(随访期,经过3个月洗脱期)的结果。主要结局为法洛四联症或主动脉缩窄修复术后早期拔管率。结果显示,随访期早期拔管率从67%降至30%(p<0.0001),首次拔管时间从4.5小时增至13.5小时(p<0.0001);重症监护和术后住院时间无差异。四家医院中仅一家维持了早期拔管率(72% vs 67%),其余三家显著下降(每家p<0.02)。结论认为,PHN CLS后第一年拔管实践回退至研究前水平,但有一家医院维持了策略,提示特定的实施和维持方法可能有效持续质量改进的影响。
要点
- PHN CLS后第一年,婴儿心脏术后早期拔管率从67%降至30%。
- 首次拔管时间从4.5小时延长至13.5小时,但ICU和住院时间无差异。
- 四家医院中仅一家维持早期拔管率,提示维持策略的重要性。
核心结论
- PHN CLS后第一年随访期,早期拔管实践回退至研究前水平。
- 四家医院中仅一家维持了早期拔管策略,提示特定实施和维持方法可能有效持续质量改进的影响。
研究设计与样本
- 将PHN CLS数据集与儿科心脏重症监护联盟登记处链接,比较四家活跃医院研究期(临床实践指南后)与研究完成后第一年(随访期,经过3个月洗脱期)的结果。
- 纳入和排除标准在各时期相同;主要结局为法洛四联症或主动脉缩窄修复术后早期拔管率。
- 研究期(临床实践指南后)121例患者,随访期139例患者,患者特征或手术亚型无差异。
主要发现
- 临床实践指南后早期拔管率从67%降至随访期的30%(p<0.0001)。
- 首次拔管时间从4.5小时增加至13.5小时(p<0.0001)。
- 一家医院维持了早期拔管率(72% vs 67%),而其他三家医院随访期显著降低(每家p<0.02)。
- 重症监护时间(2.8 vs 2.9天)和术后住院时间(6 vs 5天)在各时期无差异(两者p>0.05)。
- findings在各手术亚型中一致。
临床怎么用
- 婴儿心脏术后早期拔管实践在质量改进研究结束后可能难以维持,需关注维持策略。
- 部分医院通过特定实施和维持方法可有效持续早期拔管策略,值得借鉴。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The Pediatric Heart Network Collaborative Learning Study (PHN CLS) successfully changed practice at four hospitals to increase the rate of early extubation within 6 hours after infant heart surgery. It is unknown whether this practice continued after study completion. METHODS: We linked the PHN CLS dataset to the Pediatric Cardiac Critical Care Consortium registry to compare outcomes at four active hospitals between the study period (post-clinical practice guideline [CPG]) and the first year after study completion (follow-up) after a 3-month washout. Inclusion and exclusion criteria were the same across eras. Primary outcome was early extubation rate after tetralogy of Fallot or aortic coarctation repair. Secondary outcomes included time to first extubation and intensive care and hospital lengths of stay. RESULTS: There were 121 patients in the post-CPG era and 139 patients in the follow-up era with no difference in patient characteristics or operation subtypes. Post-CPG early extubation rate declined from 67% to 30% in follow-up (p < 0.0001); time to first extubation increased (4.5 versus 13.5 hours, p < 0.0001). One hospital maintained the rate of early extubation (72% versus 67%), whereas the other three hospitals had significantly lower rates in follow-up (p < 0.02 for each). Intensive care (2.8 versus 2.9 days) and postoperative hospital (6 versus 5 days) stays did not differ between eras (p > 0.05 for both). Findings were consistent across operation subtypes. CONCLUSIONS: Extubation practice in the first year of follow-up after the PHN CLS reverted toward prestudy levels. One of four hospitals maintained its early extubation strategy, suggesting that specific implementation and maintenance approaches may effectively sustain impact from quality initiatives.
引用
- Gaies M, Pasquali SK, Nicolson SC, et al. Sustainability of Infant Cardiac Surgery Early Extubation Practices After Implementation and Study. Ann Thorac Surg. 2018. PMID: 30391249. doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2018.09.024
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。