指南与共识肺外科

种族是否影响肺切除术的风险评估与推荐?一项随机试验

Does Race Influence Risk Assessment and Recommendations for Lung Resection? A Randomized Trial.
指南 / 共识 · Ann Thorac Surg · 2018-06-11

该随机试验让113名胸外科医生(38名执业、75名受训)阅读种族中立的肺切除候选病例简介,观看随机分配的黑人或白人标准化患者无声视频,评估重大手术并发症风险百分比及推荐手术的可能性。患者种族与医生种族均与风险估计变化和手术推荐可能性无显著关联,未能解释已记录的肺癌治疗种族差异,需进一步研究。

要点

  • 患者种族与医生种族均与风险估计变化无显著关联(p=0.11;p=0.52)。
  • 黑人标准化患者视频与白人视频推荐手术的可能性相似(p=0.90)。
  • 医生种族(白人与其他)与推荐手术的可能性无关(p=0.79)。

核心结论

  • 患者种族和医生种族均与风险估计或手术推荐无显著关联。
  • 这些发现不能为已记录的肺癌治疗种族差异提供解释。
  • 需要进一步研究以确定这些差异的机制。

研究设计与样本

  • 随机试验,将四个种族中立的肺切除候选临床病例简介与风险水平一致的标准化患者简短无声视频配对。
  • 视频随机分配为黑人标准化患者或白人标准化患者。
  • 参与者包括113名外科医生(38名执业外科医生、75名受训者);其中76名为白人非西班牙裔(67%),37名为其他自我认定的种族类别。

主要发现

  • 初始与最终风险估计之间的百分比变化与患者种族(p=0.11)或医生种族(白人与其他;p=0.52)无显著关联。
  • 黑人标准化患者视频与白人标准化患者视频相比,推荐手术的可能性相似(p=0.90)。
  • 医生种族(白人与其他)与推荐手术干预的可能性无关(p=0.79)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Racial disparities in use of surgical therapy for lung cancer exist in the United States. Videos of standardized patients (SPs) can help identify factors that influence physicians' surgical risk estimation. We hypothesized that physician race and SP race in videos influence surgeon decision making. METHODS: Four race-neutral clinical vignettes representing lung resection candidates were paired with risk-level concordant short silent videos of SPs. Vignette/video combinations were classified as low or high risk. Trainees and practicing thoracic surgeons read a race-neutral vignette, provided an initial estimate of the percentage risk of major surgical complications, viewed a video randomized to a black or white SP, provided a final estimate of risk, and scored the likelihood that they would recommend operative therapy. Changes in risk estimates were assessed. RESULTS: Participants included 113 surgeons (38 practicing surgeons, 75 trainees); of these, 76 were white non-Hispanic (67%), and 37 were other self-identified racial categories. Percentage changes between initial and final risk estimates were not significantly related to patient race (p = 0.11) or surgeon race (white versus other; p = 0.52). Videos of black SPs were associated with a similar likelihood of recommending an operation compared with that of videos of white SPs (p = 0.90). Physician race (white versus other) was not related to the likelihood of recommending surgical intervention (p = 0.79). CONCLUSIONS: Neither patient nor physician race was significantly associated with risk estimation or surgical recommendations. These findings do not provide an explanation for documented racial disparities in lung cancer therapy. Further investigation is needed to identify the mechanism underlying these disparities.

来源:Ann Thorac Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ferguson MK, Demchuk C, Wroblewski K, et al. Does Race Influence Risk Assessment and Recommendations for Lung Resection? A Randomized Trial. Ann Thorac Surg. 2018. PMID: 29902464. doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2018.04.087

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。