一专还是全专?中心内冠状动脉与瓣膜手术结局的变异性
结果死亡O/E比相关性弱(AVR与CABG r=0.22,MVR与CABG r=0.26),而发病率O/E比呈强相关(AVR系数1.03,MVR系数0.97),提示术后管理是心脏手术后发病率的主要决定因素。
要点
- 死亡O/E比在CABG与AVR间相关系数0.22,与MVR间0.26,相关性弱。
- 发病率O/E比在CABG与AVR间系数1.03、与MVR间0.97,呈近乎1:1关系。
- CABG死亡率低的中心,瓣膜手术死亡率未必同样低。
核心结论
- CABG死亡率低的中心,瓣膜手术死亡率未必同样低;但各中心CABG与瓣膜手术的发病率O/E比几乎相同,提示术后管理是心脏手术后发病率的主要决定因素。
研究设计与样本
- 基于STS多机构数据库2008至2015年记录,纳入18家机构共22258例手术:CABG 17026例、孤立AVR 3238例、MVR 1994例。
- 按术式计算各机构发病率与死亡率的O/E比,用线性回归模型评估CABG与瓣膜手术机构绩效的关系。
主要发现
- 死亡方面,AVR与CABG的相关系数为0.22,MVR与CABG为0.26,相关性弱。
- 发病率方面,AVR与CABG的O/E比系数为1.03,MVR与CABG为0.97,呈近乎1:1关系。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The technical expertise required for treatment of coronary and structural heart valve disease differs. Correlation between center-specific mortality rates after coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) and valve operations has not been demonstrated. This study tested the hypothesis that risk-adjusted outcomes between coronary and valve procedures do not correlate within centers. METHODS: Records of patients undergoing isolated CABG, isolated aortic valve replacement (AVR), or isolated mitral valve replacement (MVR) procedures from 2008 to 2015 in a multi-institutional Society of Thoracic Surgeons (STS) database were used to generate observed-to-expected (O/E) ratios for morbidity and death. Ratios were based on the STS predicted risks of morbidity and death and were calculated by procedure for each institution. Linear regression models evaluated the relationship between institutional performance in CABG and valve operations. RESULTS: A total of 22,258 records from 18 institutions were analyzed: 17,026 CABG, 3,238 isolated AVR, and 1,994 MVR procedures. With respect to deaths, the correlation coefficients were weak; for AVR and CABG, it was 0.22 and was 0.26 for MVR and CABG. With respect to morbidity, a strong relationship was seen between the morbidity O/E ratios, with coefficients of 1.03 for AVR and 0.97 for MVR, suggesting a nearly 1:1 relationship between morbidities observed in an institution's CABG and valve operations. CONCLUSIONS: Sites that perform CABG with low mortality rates may not have similarly low mortality rates with valve operations. Most striking, however, is the nearly identical O/E ratio for morbidity for CABG and valve operations at each center. These findings suggest postoperative care as a major determinant for morbidity after cardiac operation.
引用
- Johnston LE, Downs EA, Hawkins R, et al. Good at One or Good at All? Variability of Coronary and Valve Operation Outcomes Within Centers. Ann Thorac Surg. 2018. PMID: 29382508. doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2017.12.038
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。