指南与共识冠心病外科

共识衍生的冠状动脉吻合检查表揭示专家间显著差异

Consensus-Derived Coronary Anastomotic Checklist Reveals Significant Variability Among Experts.
指南 / 共识 · Ann Thorac Surg · 2017-11-01

研究通过随机邀请北美资深冠脉外科专家参与三轮德尔菲法,以75%及以上参与者将条目评为强制为阳性共识标准,从407条初始条目中筛选出40条共识条目,仅占最终146条条目的27%,各板块共识率从0%到47%不等,提示专家对冠脉搭桥吻合强制步骤存在较大分歧。

要点

  • 三轮德尔菲法后仅40条(27%)条目达成共识,专家对强制步骤分歧显著。
  • 各板块共识率差异大,从0%(助手管理)到47%(测试与最终步骤)。
  • 局部开发的检查表在广泛推广时需谨慎考虑其通用性。

核心结论

  • 随机选取的专家使用德尔菲法可生成评估冠状动脉搭桥构建的检查表。
  • 专家对哪些步骤为强制存在相当大分歧,质疑任何局部开发检查表的通用性。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究采用三轮德尔菲法,随机联系北美具有10年及以上执业经验且积极教授冠状动脉手术的专家外科医生参与。

主要发现

  • 阳性共识标准为75%或以上参与者将条目评为强制。
  • 各板块内共识率从0%(助手管理)到47%(测试与最终步骤)不等。

关键数值与推荐

  • 阳性共识定义为75%或以上参与者将条目评为强制。
  • 最终共识条目共40个,占146个条目的27%。
  • 各板块共识率范围为0%至47%。

临床怎么用

  • 使用德尔菲法生成的检查表评估冠状动脉吻合技能时,需注意专家间对强制步骤的共识有限。
  • 局部开发的检查表在广泛推广前应评估其通用性。

局限性

  • 专家对强制步骤存在较大分歧,可能影响检查表的广泛适用性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Surgical skill assessment tools frequently reflect the opinions of small groups of surgeons. That raises concerns over their generalizability as well as their utilization when applied broadly. A Delphi approach could engage a broad group of experts to identify key elements for a checklist assessing coronary anastomotic skill, improving generalizability. METHODS: Expert surgeons in North America (10 or more years in practice, actively teaching coronary artery surgery) were contacted randomly to participate. Consenting surgeons first provided items they believed were mandatory when performing a coronary artery bypass. These were then entered into a three-round Delphi. Positive consensus was reached when 75% or more of participants ranked an item mandatory. RESULTS: Sixteen faculty consented to participate. Each participant provided 25 ± 10 items. The 407 items provided were condensed, resulting in 146 items in the final list, divided into six sections based on the conduct of the operation. Twenty-three items reached consensus in the first round, 14 in the second, and 3 in the third. These 40 items represented only 27% of the initial 146 items. Agreement within sections varied widely, from 0% for "management of assistants" to 47% for "testing and final steps." CONCLUSIONS: A randomly selected group of experts using a Delphi approach can generate a checklist to assess construction of a coronary artery bypass. Considerable disagreement among experts regarding what steps are mandatory calls into question the generalizability of any locally developed checklist.

来源:Ann Thorac Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Vaporciyan AA, Fikfak V, Lineberry MC, et al. Consensus-Derived Coronary Anastomotic Checklist Reveals Significant Variability Among Experts. Ann Thorac Surg. 2017. PMID: 29074155. doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2017.07.029

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。