两种微创技术与胸骨正中切开在主动脉瓣置换术中的比较
该研究对2005至2013年接受孤立主动脉瓣置换术的患者进行倾向性评分匹配分析,比较部分胸骨上段切开、前外侧小切口与胸骨正中切开三种入路。结果显示前外侧小切口组围术期并发症更多,而部分胸骨上段切开与胸骨正中切开围术期结果相似,因此推荐部分胸骨上段切开作为微创主动脉瓣置换的常规首选技术。
要点
- 前外侧小切口组转胸骨正中切开率、二次转机及二次阻断率更高,跨钳与灌注时间更长。
- 部分胸骨上段切开与胸骨正中切开围术期结果无差异。
- 三组1年生存无显著差异,部分胸骨上段切开组生存有更好趋势。
核心结论
- 在微创孤立主动脉瓣置换中,部分胸骨上段切开围术期结果与胸骨正中切开相似,而前外侧小切口围术期并发症更多,因此部分胸骨上段切开应作为常规首选微创技术。
研究设计与样本
- 2005至2013年单中心回顾性队列,孤立主动脉瓣置换患者中部分胸骨上段切开315例(38.9%)、胸骨正中切开328例(40.5%)、前外侧小切口167例(20.6%)。
- 经倾向性评分匹配后,两种微创技术分别与胸骨正中切开各形成118对匹配队列进行比较。
主要发现
- 前外侧小切口组转胸骨正中切开17例(14.4%)、二次转机6例(5.1%)、二次阻断12例(10.2%),均显著高于胸骨正中切开组。
- 前外侧小切口组中位跨钳时间94分钟(范围43至231分钟)、中位灌注时间141分钟(范围77至456分钟),均显著长于胸骨正中切开组。
- 前外侧小切口组腹股沟并发症17例(14.4%),显著多于胸骨正中切开组。
- 部分胸骨上段切开组与胸骨正中切开组围术期结果无差异。
- 三组1年生存无显著差异,部分胸骨上段切开组生存有更好趋势。
临床怎么用
- 在常规微创孤立主动脉瓣置换中优先选择部分胸骨上段切开,因其围术期结果与胸骨正中切开相似。
- 前外侧小切口因转开胸、二次转机、二次阻断及腹股沟并发症较多,不宜作为广泛外科医生的常规首选。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Propensity score-matched analysis of the anterolateral minithoracotomy and the partial upper hemisternotomy vs the median sternotomy approach has not been reported to date for isolated aortic valve replacement. METHODS: From 2005 to 2013, isolated aortic valve replacement was performed through a partial upper hemisternotomy in 315 patients (38.9%), through a median sternotomy in 328 patients (40.5%), and through an anterolateral minithoracotomy in 167 patients (20.6%). After propensity score-matched analysis, both minimally invasive techniques were independently compared with median sternotomy in 118 matched pairs. RESULTS: In the anterolateral group, conversion to median sternotomy was significantly higher (17 [14.4%]), a second pump run (6 [5.1%]) and second cross clamp (12 [10.2%]) were significantly more often necessary, the median cross-clamp time (94 minutes; range, 43 to 231 minutes) and median perfusion time (141 minutes; range, 77 to 456 minutes) were significantly longer, and more groin complications occurred (17 [14.4%]), all compared with the median sternotomy group. No difference in perioperative results was identified between the partial upper hemisternotomy and the median sternotomy group. There was no significant difference in 1-year survival among the three groups, although a trend of better survival was observed in the partial upper hemisternotomy group. CONCLUSIONS: In minimally invasive isolated aortic valve replacement, the partial upper hemisternotomy shows similar perioperative outcome as the median sternotomy, whereas, the anterolateral minithoracotomy is associated with more perioperative complications. Therefore, only the partial upper hemisternotomy should be the preferred surgical technique for minimally invasive aortic valve replacement in the daily routine for a broad spectrum of surgeons.
引用
- Semsroth S, Matteucci Gothe R, Raith YR, et al. Comparison of Two Minimally Invasive Techniques and Median Sternotomy in Aortic Valve Replacement. Ann Thorac Surg. 2017. PMID: 28433220. doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2017.01.095
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。