电磁导航支气管镜与CT引导经胸标记在肺结节定位中的随机对照试验
本研究为单中心1:1随机对照试验,比较电磁导航支气管镜(NAVIB)使用吲哚菁绿与CT引导经胸标记(CTI)使用锝-99m在单孔楔形切除术中的效果。主要终点手术时长两组相似(NAVIB中位52.5分钟 vs CTI 45分钟,p=0.664),但CTI楔形切除时间更短(12分钟 vs 15.5分钟,p=0.0007),外科医生满意度评分CTI更高(中位3分 vs 2.5分,p=0.045),经Bonferroni校正后问卷差异不显著。结论为两种方法在总体手术时长上无显著差异。
要点
- NAVIB与CTI在总体手术时长上无显著差异(中位52.5 vs 45分钟,p=0.664)。
- CTI楔形切除时间显著短于NAVIB(中位12 vs 15.5分钟,p=0.0007)。
- CTI外科医生满意度评分更高(中位3 vs 2.5分,p=0.045),但校正后不显著。
核心结论
- 随机试验未能证明电磁导航支气管镜与CT引导经胸标记在总体手术时长上有显著差异。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心1:1随机对照试验,共随机63例患者,NAVIB组32例,CTI组31例,比较单孔楔形切除术中两种术前标记方法。
主要发现
- 手术时长中位数NAVIB组52.5分钟(IQR 40-70),CTI组45分钟(IQR 30-60),p=0.664。
- 楔形切除时间中位数NAVIB组15.5分钟(IQR 13-20),CTI组12分钟(IQR 9-15),p=0.0007。
- II级或以上并发症发生率NAVIB组9.4%,CTI组12.9%,p=0.144。
- 病灶距缝合线距离NAVIB组5.7mm(CI 4.2-7.2),CTI组7.0mm(CI 4.3-9.9),p=0.355。
- 医生满意度问卷(0-3分)中位评分CTI组3分(IQR 3-3),NAVIB组2.5分(IQR 2-3),p=0.045;经Bonferroni校正后差异不显著。
临床怎么用
- 在单孔楔形切除肺结节术前标记中,NAVIB与CTI总体手术时长相当,可根据可用性和术者偏好选择。
- CTI可能缩短楔形切除时间并提高术者满意度,但需考虑校正后差异不显著。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Electromagnetic navigational bronchoscopy (NAVIB) and CT-guided transthoracic marking (CTI) are two possible methods for preoperative marking. We have conducted a study to determine whether one technique performs better in a selected patient population. METHODS: In a single-center, 1:1 randomized controlled trial we compared NAVIB using indocyanine green and CTI with Technetium-99m during uniportal wedge resections of lung nodules. Primary endpoint was the duration of surgery. Secondary endpoints included wedge resection time, complication rates, surgical margin, and surgeon satisfaction questionnaires. RESULTS: 63 patients were randomized, with 32 assigned to the NAVIB and 31 to the CTI group. Surgeries' duration was similar, with a median of 52.5 minutes (IQR:40-70) for NAVIB and 45 minutes for CTI (IQR:30-60;p= 0.664). The median wedge time for NAVIB was 15.5 minutes (IQR: 13-20), while for CTI it was 12 minutes (IQR: 9-15;p=0.0007). Grade II or higher complication rates were 9.4% for NAVIB vs 12.9% for CTI; (p = 0.144) and lesion's distance to staple line was 5.7mm (CI:4.2-7.2) vs. 7.0mm (CI:4.3-9.9) respectively (p = 0.355). In the questionnaire from 0 (not helpful) to 3 (very helpful), CTI received a median score of 3 (IQR;3-3), while NAVIB's was 2.5 (IQR;2-3;p = 0.045). After Bonferroni correction, questionnaire differences were not significant. CONCLUSIONS: The randomized trial failed to demonstrate a significant difference in overall surgery duration between electromagnetic navigational bronchoscopy and computed tomography-guided transthoracic marking.
引用
- Csaba M, Megyesfalvi Z, Salamon A, et al. Electromagnetic bronchoscopy versus computed tomography for pulmonary nodule localization. Interdiscip Cardiovasc Thorac Surg. 2026. PMID: 42928610. doi:10.1093/icvts/ivag283
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。