英国孤立性冠状动脉旁路移植术培训机会存在不合理差异
该研究基于英国国家成人心脏手术审计数据库2010至2019年数据,纳入127795例首次孤立性CABG患者,其中25.8%由 trainees 作为主要术者。倾向性评分匹配后,trainee 主刀病例体外循环和阻断时间更长,但院内死亡率、术后透析和重返手术室无差异。多水平模型显示,校正患者因素后,trainee 主刀机会在医院和顾问层面仍存在显著残余变异,医院层面变异占比更大。
要点
- Trainee 主刀孤立性CABG占25.8%,匹配后死亡等结局与顾问主刀无差异。
- 校正病例组合后,trainee 主刀机会在医院和顾问层面仍存在不合理变异。
- 医院层面变异大于顾问层面,提示培训机会分配需更标准化和透明。
核心结论
- 英国孤立性CABG培训机会在医院和顾问层面存在大量不合理变异,校正患者病例组合和手术因素后仍持续存在。
研究设计与样本
- 基于英国国家成人心脏手术审计数据库的回顾性队列研究,纳入2010至2019年127795例首次择期或急诊孤立性CABG成人患者。
主要发现
- trainee 作为主要术者记录于32997例(25.8%)。
- 倾向性评分匹配后,trainee 主刀病例体外循环时间85 vs 81分钟、主动脉阻断时间50 vs 48分钟,均 p < 0.001。
- 匹配后 trainee 主刀与顾问主刀在院内死亡率(0.9% vs 1.2%)、术后透析(1.4% vs 1.8%)、重返手术室(3.7% vs 3.8%)方面无差异。
- 多水平模型中,医院层面变异分区系数(VPC)为43.7%,顾问层面VPC为25.1%,其余归因于患者术前特征。
- 医院层面中位比值比(MOR)为7.76,顾问层面MOR为4.72。
临床怎么用
- 心胸外科培训体系应关注医院和顾问层面 trainee 主刀机会的不合理差异,推动更标准化、透明和公平的手术暴露监测。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Several studies have reported comparable outcomes between trainees and consultants performing isolated coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG). However, the extent to which trainee operating opportunities vary between consultants and hospitals after accounting for patient risk profile remains unclear. METHODS: Adult patients undergoing first-time, elective or urgent isolated CABG in the United Kingdom between 2010 and 2019 were identified from the National Adult Cardiac Surgery Audit database. Procedures in which a trainee was recorded as the primary operator were compared with those with consultant. Three-level multilevel logistic regression models quantified hospital- and consultant-level variation after adjustment for perioperative factors. RESULTS: A total of 127,795 patients were included; a trainee was recorded as the primary operator in 32,997 cases (25.8%). After propensity score matching, trainee primary operator cases had longer bypass and cross-clamp times (85 vs 81 minutes and 50 vs 48 minutes, respectively; both p < 0.001) but were not associated with higher in-hospital mortality (0.9% vs 1.2%), postoperative dialysis (1.4% vs 1.8%), or return to theatre (3.7% vs 3.8%).In the final multilevel model, residual variation in trainee primary operator status was observed at both hospital and consultant levels. Hospitals accounted for a larger proportion of variation (variance partition coefficient [VPC] 43.7%) than consultants (VPC 25.1%), with the rest of the variation attributed to patient preoperative characteristics. The median odds ratio (MOR) was 7.76 at the hospital level and 4.72 at the consultant level, indicating that, for two otherwise similar patients, moving from a lower- to a higher-training hospital would multiply the odds of trainee primary operator involvement by almost eight. CONCLUSIONS: Substantial unwarranted variation exists in trainee operating opportunities for isolated CABG at the hospital and consultant levels in the United Kingdom. This variation persists after adjustment for patient case mix and operative factors, supporting the need for more standardised, transparent, and equitable monitoring of operative exposure across institutions.
引用
- Chan J, Comanici M, Dong T, et al. Unwarranted variation in training in isolated coronary artery bypass grafting in the United Kingdom. Interdiscip Cardiovasc Thorac Surg. 2026. PMID: 42788686. doi:10.1093/icvts/ivag270
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。