多孔与单孔胸腔镜肺切除术的比较综述
本文为叙述性综述与定性分析,比较单孔(UVATS)与多孔(MVATS)胸腔镜解剖性肺切除的文献。现有证据总体提示UVATS安全性相当、术后结局相似或略优(尤其减痛)、肿瘤学结局相当、学习曲线相近,近年的比较研究科学性更强且评估指标更广。
要点
- UVATS与MVATS安全性相当,术后结局相似或略优。
- UVATS在减轻术后疼痛方面可能略有优势。
- 两者淋巴结检出与中期生存等肿瘤学结局相当。
核心结论
- 十余年比较验证UVATS已成为微创肺切除主流术式,直接比较多显示其相对MVATS非劣效。
- 比较过程的真正价值在于提升良好临床研究规范并增进对患者相关结局指标的认识。
研究设计与样本
- 叙述性综述与定性分析,检索并汇总UVATS特别是UVATS与MVATS比较的文献。
主要发现
- UVATS相比MVATS:安全性相当。
- UVATS相比MVATS:术后结局相似或略好,尤其在减少疼痛方面。
- UVATS相比MVATS:以淋巴结检出数和中期生存衡量的肺癌治疗结局相当。
- UVATS与MVATS的学习曲线大体相似。
- 近年比较UVATS与MVATS的研究科学性更严谨,并探究更广泛的临床相关结局指标。
临床怎么用
- 可将UVATS视为微创肺切除的主流术式之一,其与MVATS比较总体呈非劣效。
- 临床比较不同术式时应关注与患者最相关的结局指标并遵循良好临床研究规范。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: There have been many attempts to compare Uniportal Video-Assisted Thoracic Surgery (UVATS) with Multiportal VATS (MVATS) for anatomic lung resection. A review is warranted to appreciate: what has been learnt about the relative benefits of the 2 approaches; what lessons have been learned by the process of comparing approaches; and whether such comparisons should influence surgical practice. METHODS: A narrative review and qualitative analysis of the literature pertaining to UVATS and especially to comparisons between UVATS and MVATS was conducted. RESULTS: The balance of currently published evidence suggests that UVATS offers the following when compared to MVATS: equivalent safety; similar or slightly better post-operative outcomes (especially in reducing pain); equivalent treatment outcomes for lung cancer (measured by lymph node yields and medium-term survival); and broadly similar learning curves. There has been a general trend for studies comparing UVATS with MVATS in recent years to exhibit greater scientific rigor and to investigate a broader range of clinically relevant outcome measures. CONCLUSIONS: Over a decade's worth of comparisons between UVATS and MVATS have validated UVATS as a mainstream approach for minimally invasive pulmonary resections. The direct comparisons have generally suggested non-inferiority vis-à-vis MVATS. However, the true value of the ongoing process of comparison lies in its elevation of good clinical research practices and increasing awareness of those outcome measures most pertinent to patients.
引用
- Sihoe ADL. Multiport Versus Single-Port Video-Assisted Thoracic Surgery for Pulmonary Resection. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2026. PMID: 42102245. doi:10.1093/ejcts/ezaf485
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。