不同微创主动脉瓣置换技术的比较:系统综述与网络Meta分析
主要结局死亡在三种技术间无差异;TT体外循环与阻断时间更长,但ICU停留、住院时间更短,神经系统事件与出血更少。因均为观察性研究,结论需谨慎解读。
要点
- 三种微创技术死亡无差异,TT的p-score为0.31,MS为0.85
- TT体外循环与阻断时间更长,但ICU与住院时间更短、出血更少
- MT除手术时间更长、ICU停留更短外,其余结局与MS相似
核心结论
- TT相比MS可能缩短住院时间、减少神经系统并发症和出血,但手术时间更长。
- 三种技术死亡率无差异,因均为观察性研究,结论需谨慎解读。
研究设计与样本
- 系统检索Medline、Web of Science、Scopus、Wiley Online Library、Google Scholar和ProQuest。
- 以MS为参照,基于p-score进行排序,p-score越高表示优于竞争干预的确定性越大。
主要发现
- 死亡率在MS(p-score 0.85)、MT(0.34)与TT(0.31)间无差异。
- TT体外循环时间较MS延长(MD 41.04,95%CI 10.98-71.10),阻断时间延长(MD 30.31,95%CI 5.81-54.80)。
- TT的ICU停留最短(p-score 0.98 > 0.51 > 0.01;MD -16.00,95%CI -26.62至-5.38),住院时间缩短(MD -2.07,95%CI -3.77至-0.37)。
- TT较MS神经系统事件更少(OR 1.79,95%CI 1.03-3.13),出血更少(MD 208.85 mL,95%CI 102.29-315.40)。
- MT较MS手术时间更长(MD 29.84,95%CI 8.35-51.32),ICU停留更短(MD -5.88,95%CI -11.10至-0.67)。
临床怎么用
- 在选择微创主动脉瓣置换技术时,可将TT作为缩短住院和减少神经系统事件与出血的选项之一。
- 需权衡TT较长的体外循环与阻断时间,以及MT较长的手术时间。
局限性
- 所有纳入研究均为观察性研究, findings应谨慎解读。
- 需进一步开展仅纳入随机试验的网络Meta分析。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This investigation aimed to compare different minimally invasive techniques, namely, mini-sternotomy (MS), mini-thoracotomy (MT), and totally thoracoscopic (TT) approaches for the surgical treatment of aortic valve disease, emphasizing their respective benefits and limitations to guide clinical decision-making. METHODS: A systematic search was conducted in Medline, Web of Science, Scopus, Wiley Online Library, Google Scholar, and ProQuest. Studies were appraised using the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale. A frequentist network meta-analysis (NMA) with a random-effects model was employed to give reflective ranks and compare outcomes across techniques. Treatment ranking was based on p-scores, with MS as the reference. Higher p-scores indicate greater certainty of superiority over competing interventions. The primary outcome was mortality. RESULTS: Twenty-five observational studies (n = 34 573 patients) were included. Mortality did not differ between techniques (p-score: MS [0.85] ∼ MT [0.34] ∼ TT [0.31]). TT had longer cardiopulmonary bypass (mean difference [MD]: 41.04 [95% CI, 10.98-71.10]) and cross-clamp times (MD: 30.31 [95% CI, 5.81-54.80]) but offered the shortest intensive care unit (ICU) length of stay (p-score: TT [0.98] > MT [0.51] > MS [0.01]; MD: -16.00 [95% CI, -26.62 to -5.38]), reduced hospital stay (MD: -2.07 [95% CI, -3.77 to -0.37]), and fewer complications, including neurological events (odds ratio: 1.79 [95% CI, 1.03-3.13]), blood loss (MD: 208.85 mL [95% CI, 102.29-315.40]) compared to MS. MT showed similar outcomes to MS, except for longer operative times (MD: 29.84 [95% CI, 8.35-51.32]) and shorter ICU stays (MD: -5.88 [95% CI, -11.10 to -0.67]). CONCLUSIONS: TT may offer advantages such as shorter hospital stays, reduced neurological complications, and less bleeding as compared to MS, although it is associated with longer operative times. However, as all included studies were observational, the findings should be interpreted with caution, and further NMA including only randomized trials is warranted.
引用
- Husen TF, Vidya AP, Heuts S, et al. Comparative Study of Different Minimally Invasive Aortic Valve Replacement Techniques: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis. Interdiscip Cardiovasc Thorac Surg. 2025. PMID: 41071046. doi:10.1093/icvts/ivaf244
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。