共识的代价:胸部肿瘤学出版中的审稿人分歧、编辑动态与影响力
该研究回顾分析2021年投稿至EJCTS的144篇胸部肿瘤学稿件,每篇由2-4名盲审审稿人评估。审稿人一致性低(Fleiss kappa=-0.03),但审稿人数增多(IRR=1.16,P=0.004)和审稿轮次增加(IRR=1.21,P<0.001)独立预测引用数增加。编辑周期延长与下载量轻微降低相关(每周-0.9%,P=0.048)。
要点
- 胸部肿瘤学稿件审稿人共识罕见,完全一致仅9.5%。
- 审稿人数和轮次增加独立预测引用数升高。
- 编辑周期延长与下载量轻微降低相关。
核心结论
- 审稿人共识在胸部肿瘤学投稿中不常见,但审稿人参与度(数量和轮次)增加独立关联于更好的文献计量影响力。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2021年投稿至EJCTS的144篇胸部肿瘤学稿件,每篇由2-4名盲审审稿人评估,审稿推荐按序数编码。
主要发现
- 审稿人一致性低:Fleiss kappa=-0.03,Krippendorff alpha=0.041,完全一致仅9.5%。
- 审稿人数增加与分歧增大相关,但更高审稿人数(IRR=1.16,P=0.004)和额外审稿轮次(IRR=1.21,P<0.001)独立预测引用数增加。
- 编辑周期延长与下载量轻微降低相关(每周-0.9%,P=0.048)。
临床怎么用
- 在保持编辑效率的前提下,结构化审稿人视角多样性可能丰富同行评审并促进学术传播。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Peer review remains central to scientific publishing; yet, its reliability and true influence on scientific visibility remain debated, especially within subspecialized fields such as thoracic oncology. We aimed to evaluate reviewer agreement in manuscripts submitted to the European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery (EJCTS) and to examine whether review intensity predicts bibliometric outcomes. METHODS: A retrospective analysis of 144 thoracic oncology manuscripts submitted in 2021 was conducted. Each was assessed by 2-4 blinded reviewers. Reviewer recommendations were coded ordinally. Agreement was quantified using Fleiss' kappa, Cohen's kappa, and Krippendorff's alpha, while reviewer heterogeneity was assessed through entropy metrics. Citation and download counts were modelled using negative binomial regression adjusted for manuscript type and time to publication. RESULTS: Reviewer concordance was low (Fleiss' kappa = -0.03; Krippendorff's alpha = 0.041), with complete agreement observed in only 9.5% of manuscripts. Increasing the number of reviewers was associated with greater disagreement. Nevertheless, both higher reviewer count (inter-rater reliability [IRR] = 1.16; P = 0.004) and additional review rounds (IRR = 1.21; P < 0.001) independently predicted increased citation counts. Longer editorial timelines were associated with slightly reduced downloads (-0.9% per week; P = 0.048). CONCLUSIONS: Reviewer consensus is uncommon in thoracic oncology submissions. However, greater reviewer engagement-both in number and iteration-was independently associated with improved bibliometric impact. These findings suggest that structured diversity of reviewer perspectives may enrich peer review and enhance scholarly dissemination, provided that editorial efficiency is preserved. This supports the view that disagreement among reviewers, when properly managed, may act as a catalyst rather than a constraint in scientific dissemination.
引用
- Bertolaccini L, Falcoz PE. The Price of Consensus: Reviewer Disagreement, Editorial Dynamics, and Impact in Thoracic Oncology Publishing. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2025. PMID: 41148049. doi:10.1093/ejcts/ezaf375
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。