改进先天性心脏病中心手术质量评估中的风险调整
该研究基于胸外科医师学会先天性数据库2016-2022年115个中心的42,579例基准手术,比较标准混合效应逻辑回归与三种因果推断加权方法(EBW、SBW、CBPS)估计中心预期手术死亡率。结果显示加权方法构建的比较组病例组合更匹配目标中心,预期死亡率估计略高且变异更大,在低手术量中心差异最明显。
要点
- 因果推断加权法使比较组病例组合更接近目标中心。
- 加权法预期死亡率估计略高于标准回归且变异更大。
- 低手术量中心中不同方法间差异最大。
核心结论
- 因果推断方法能构建更量身定制的比较组来估计中心预期死亡率,病例组合对齐更好,可能值得采用新方法。
研究设计与样本
- 基于胸外科医师学会先天性数据库2016-2022年115个中心的42,579例基准手术,比较标准混合效应逻辑回归与三种加权方法(EBW、SBW、CBPS)估计中心预期手术死亡率。
主要发现
- 42,579例基准手术总体手术死亡率为2.37%。
- 中心平均(IQR)回归法预期死亡率为2.03%(IQR 1.42%-2.58%),低于加权估计:EBW 2.10%(IQR 1.64%-2.67%)、SBW 2.09%(IQR 1.57%-2.69%)、CBPS 2.10%(IQR 1.63%-2.66%),且回归法变异更小。
- 加权估计与回归估计的均值比为1.03,IQR分别为EBW 0.89-1.16、SBW 0.87-1.15、CBPS 0.92-1.17。
- 加权估计中手术类型和其他风险因素的分布与目标中心更对齐。
- 不同方法间最大差异出现在较小手术量中心。
临床怎么用
- 在评估先天性心脏病中心手术质量时,可考虑使用因果推断加权方法以更精准地调整病例组合。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Understanding center performance in congenital heart surgery remains challenging, with limitations to standard regression approaches. Modern causal inference methods may improve estimation of expected mortality through better balancing case mix but have not been studied. METHODS: Benchmark operations across 115 centers (2016-2022) from The Society of Thoracic Surgeons Congenital Database were included. The standard approach uses mixed-effects logistic regression to estimate centers' expected operative mortality inclusive of all patients, even those treated at the center of interest ("target") and those from other centers regardless of how closely aligned with the target they are. The causal approach creates tailored comparison groups, including only similar patients from other centers, by using weights. The study used 3 different weights (entropy balancing weight [EBW], stable balancing weight [SBW], and covariate balancing propensity score [CBPS]) and compared them with standard regression. RESULTS: Among 42,579 benchmark operations, overall operative mortality was 2.37%. Centers' mean (25th-75th percentiles [interquartile range; IQR]) regression-based expected mortality was lower (2.03% [IQR, 1.42%-2.58%]) than weighted estimates (EBW, 2.10% [IQR, 1.64%-2.67%]; SBW, 2.09% [IQR, 1.57%-2.69%]; CBPS, 2.10% [IQR, 1.63%-2.66%]) and less variable. The mean ratio of weighted to regression mortality estimate was 1.03 for all estimates, with IQRs: EBW [IQR, 0.89-1.16], SBW [IQR, 0.87-1.15], and CBPS [IQR, 0.92-1.17]. The distributions of operation type and other risk factors were better aligned with the target center in weighted estimates. The largest differences among methods were observed at smaller-volume centers. CONCLUSIONS: Causal inference methods constructed more tailored comparison groups for estimating centers' expected mortality, with better alignment of case mix. Adoption of newer approaches may be warranted.
引用
- Normand SL, Zelevinsky K, Han L, et al. Improving Risk Adjustment in the Assessment of Congenital Heart Center Surgical Quality. Ann Thorac Surg. 2025. PMID: 40953790. doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2025.08.047
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。