英国和爱尔兰2021年心胸外科新课程要求下16年受训者手术经验分析
该研究基于英国和爱尔兰2021年心胸外科新课程要求,回顾性分析2007年起进入高级心胸外科培训的290名受训者手术日志,评估完成250例主刀大手术的可行性及COVID-19影响。结果显示中位总手术量为378例,心脏与胸科方向受训者达到250例分别需6.25年和5.25年,且疫情前后培训完成时间显著延长。
要点
- 新课程要求250例主刀大手术,多数受训者总手术量可满足该目标。
- 心脏方向受训者达到250例中位需6.25年,胸科方向需5.25年。
- COVID-19前后高级培训完成时间从6年延长至7年(P=0.01)。
核心结论
- 2021年新课程要求的250例主刀大手术目标看似可行,但疫情后手术量下降及基础外科培训取消需整合改革以确保7年内完成培训。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2007年起进入高级心胸外科培训并毕业的受训者,共纳入290人,其中145人(50%)完成培训并有验证的电子日志。
主要发现
- 所有受训者培训期间中位记录手术量为378例(IQR:309,474)。
- 心脏方向受训者中位记录378例(IQR:312.5,474.5),其中冠状动脉旁路移植术202例(IQR:166.5,257.0),主动脉瓣手术39例(14%,IQR:15,54.5)。
- 胸科方向受训者中位记录383.5例(IQR:304.5,469.75),其中解剖性肺切除345例(IQR:270.25,457.75),继发性气胸手术124例(35%,IQR:100.25,165.0)。
- 心脏和胸科方向受训者达到250例的中位时间分别为6.25年和5.25年。
- COVID-19疫情前与疫情期间/之后相比,完成高级外科培训的中位时间从6年(IQR:5,8)延长至7年(IQR:6,10),P=0.01。
关键数值与推荐
- 新课程为7年制、基于结果,要求至少250例主刀大手术。
- 手术量分为13种主要手术(6种心脏、7种胸科)。
临床怎么用
- 培训项目需关注心脏方向受训者达到250例所需时间接近7年上限,并应对疫情后手术量下降采取补充措施。
局限性
- 仅50%受训者具有验证的电子日志数据,可能存在选择偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Before introducing the new 7-year curriculum in 2021, cardiothoracic surgery trainees were required to complete a 2-year basic surgical training programme followed by 6 years of higher speciality training. The new curriculum eliminates the need for basic surgical training. It is outcome-based, requiring a minimum of 250 major cases performed as the first operator. We assess trainees' operative experiences over the past 16 years based on the requirements of the new curriculum. The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on training was also investigated. PARTICIPANTS: All trainees who commenced higher cardiothoracic surgical training from 2007 and graduated were included. Operative volumes were categorised into 13 major procedures (6 cardiac and 7 thoracic). The total number of major cases logged and the time required to achieve 250 cases were evaluated. RESULTS: A total of 290 trainees were included, of whom 145 (50%) had completed training with validated eLogbooks. The median number of cases logged was 378 (interquartile range [IQR]: 309, 474) for all trainees across their training period. Cardiac-themed trainees logged 378 (IQR: 312.5, 474.5) cases, of which 202 (IQR: 166.5, 257.0) were coronary artery bypass grafting, followed by aortic valve surgery (n = 39, 14%, IQR: 15, 54.5). Thoracic-themed trainees logged 383.5 (IQR: 304.5, 469.75) cases, of which 345 (IQR: 270.25, 457.75) were anatomical lung resections followed by surgery for secondary pneumothorax (n = 124, 35%, IQR: 100.25, 165.0). The median time required to achieve 250 cases was 6.25 and 5.25 years for cardiac and thoracic trainees, respectively. There was an increase in time for trainees to complete higher surgical training before and during/after the COVID-19 pandemic (median 6 [IQR: 5, 8] vs 7 [IQR: 6, 10] years, P = 0.01). CONCLUSION: The new 2021 curriculum's target of 250 major cases appears feasible. However, post-COVID-19 reductions in surgical volume and the removal of basic surgical training require integration and reform to ensure trainees can complete the programme in the 7-year timeframe.
引用
- Chan J, Fudulu DP, Dong T, et al. An Analysis of Trainees' Operative Experiences Over the Past 16 Years Based on the Requirements of the New 2021 Cardiothoracic Surgery Curriculum in the United Kingdom and Ireland. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2025. PMID: 40632614. doi:10.1093/ejcts/ezaf228
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。