机器人二尖瓣修复学习曲线:两中心前瞻性熟练度与临床结局研究
该研究回顾性分析了两家欧洲中心首批连续机器人二尖瓣修复病例,比较从传统开放手术转型(中心1)与从微创小切口二尖瓣手术转型(中心2)的学习曲线差异。结果显示中心2手术时间更短,但两中心联合主要结局无显著差异,提示两种背景均可安全启动机器人项目,而既往微创经验有助于缩短学习曲线。
要点
- 既往微创二尖瓣手术经验可缩短机器人二尖瓣修复的学习曲线。
- 从传统开放或微创小切口背景均可安全启动机器人二尖瓣修复项目。
- 中心2的体外循环、主动脉阻断及总手术时间均显著短于中心1。
核心结论
- 从传统开放或微创小切口二尖瓣手术背景均可安全启动机器人二尖瓣修复项目。
- 既往微创小切口二尖瓣手术经验对初始学习曲线有积极影响。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析两欧洲中心首批连续因重度退行性二尖瓣反流行机器人手术的病例。
- 中心1从传统手术转型,中心2从微创小切口二尖瓣手术转型,各纳入前62例。
- 采用累积和(CUSUM)分析评估手术时间及联合主要结局的学习过程。
主要发现
- 中心2的中位体外循环时间115 min vs 中心1 238 min,P < 0.001。
- 中心2的中位主动脉阻断时间82 min vs 中心1 143 min,P < 0.001。
- 中心2的中位总手术时间228 min vs 中心1 313 min,P < 0.001。
- 联合主要结局无显著差异(9.7% vs 8%;P = 1)。
- 学习阶段终点中心1在第60例,中心2在第50例;手术时间学习曲线中心1体外循环及阻断均在32例后跨越学习阶段,中心2为16例。
临床怎么用
- 既往有微创小切口二尖瓣手术经验的外科团队可更快度过机器人学习曲线。
- 无微创经验但具备传统开放手术基础的团队亦可安全开展机器人二尖瓣修复。
局限性
- 回顾性设计,样本量有限(每中心62例),结论需更大样本验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Robotic-assisted mitral valve repair surgery has a steep learning curve, and it is not clear whether previous experience in minimally invasive mitral valve surgery (MIMVS) facilitates this process. We aimed to investigate the initial experience of 2 cardiac centres starting their robotic programmes, evaluating the impact of previous MIMVS experience. METHODS: Retrospective analysis was performed for the 1st consecutive cases operated due to severe degenerative mitral valve regurgitation using the robotic surgical platform in 2 European centres, 1 transitioning from conventional surgery (centre 1) and the other from mini thoracotomy MIMVS (centre 2). Cumulative sum analysis was used to evaluate the learning process using both surgical times and a combined primary outcome including relevant intra- and postoperative results. RESULTS: First 62 patients in each centre were included. All median surgical times were shorter in centre 2: cardiopulmonary bypass: 238 vs 115 min, P < 0.001; cross-clamp: 143 vs 82 min, P < 0.001; and total intervention: 313 vs 228 min, P < 0.001. The combined primary outcome showed no significant differences (9.7% vs 8%; P = 1). However, the turning point making the end of the learning phase was detected at the 60th case in centre 1 and at the 50th in centre 2. Regarding surgical time, the learning curve was steeper in centre 1 with both cardiopulmonary bypass and cross-clamp overcoming the learning phase after 32 cases, as compared to 16 cases in centre 2. CONCLUSIONS: A successful robotic-assisted mitral repair programme can be safely started coming from either conventional open approach or mini thoracotomy MIMVS. However, previous mini thoracotomy MIMVS experience had positive impact on the initial learning curve.
引用
- Sandoval E, Bhoera RA, Tomšič A, et al. Learning curve of robotic mitral repair: prospective two-centre study of proficiency and clinical outcomes. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2024. PMID: 39589894. doi:10.1093/ejcts/ezae426
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。