胸科肿瘤外科区域化对长期结局的影响
加拿大安大略省2007年实施胸科肿瘤外科标准,将肺叶切除、食管切除和全肺切除集中至指定中心。该人群水平分析纳入22195例手术,采用多层回归与中断时间序列分析,发现30天和90天死亡率及住院时间在研究期间改善,但中断时间序列分析未显示区域化本身对上述结局有统计学显著影响。
要点
- 区域化后>99%病例在指定中心完成,肺叶切除和食管切除年均例数增加,全肺切除减少
- 肺叶切除和食管切除的30天、90天死亡率及住院时间改善,全肺切除90天死亡率亦改善
- 中断时间序列分析未能将结局改善归因于区域化,改善与既有趋势并行
核心结论
- 2003至2020年安大略省胸科肿瘤手术死亡率和住院时间持续改善,但分析未将这些改善归因于包括区域化在内的胸科肿瘤外科标准的实施。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为基于加拿大安大略省的人群水平分析,纳入接受肺叶切除、食管切除或全肺切除的患者。
- 采用多层回归模型比较区域化前、中、后的30天和90天死亡率及住院时间,并用中断时间序列模型控制既有趋势。
- 研究期间共完成22195例手术,包括14902例肺叶切除、4958例食管切除和2408例全肺切除。
主要发现
- 区域化后>99%的病例在指定中心完成。
- 区域化后指定中心年均肺叶切除和食管切除例数增加,全肺切除例数减少。
- 研究期间肺叶切除和食管切除的30天及90天死亡率、住院时间改善,全肺切除的90天死亡率亦改善。
- 中断时间序列分析未显示区域化对这些结局有独立于既有趋势的统计学显著影响。
临床怎么用
- 结果提示胸科肿瘤手术结局的改善可能反映省级层面既有趋势,区域化标准本身的独立贡献尚未被证实。
- 在解读区域化政策效果时,需区分集中化实施与同期整体医疗质量改善的作用。
局限性
- 原文未报告具体死亡率数值、置信区间及P值。
- 中断时间序列分析未发现区域化的统计学显著效应,无法排除其他同期因素对结局改善的影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In 2007, Cancer Care Ontario created Thoracic Surgical Oncology Standards for the delivery of surgery, including lobectomy, esophagectomy, and pneumonectomy. These standards regionalized thoracic surgery into designated centers and mandated physical and human resources. This analysis sought to identify the impact of these standards, hereafter referred to as "regionalization," on outcomes after thoracic oncology surgery in Ontario, Canada. METHODS: This study was a population-level analysis of patients undergoing lobectomy, esophagectomy, or pneumonectomy, and it used multilevel regression models to compare 30- and 90-day mortality and length of stay before, during, and after regionalization. Interrupted time series models were used to assess for an impact of regionalization while controlling for ongoing trends. RESULTS: A total of 22,195 surgical procedures (14,902 lobectomies, 4958 esophagectomies, and 2408 pneumonectomies) were performed within the study period. A total of >99% of cases were performed at a designated center after regionalization. Mean annual volumes per designated center increased after regionalization for lobectomy and esophagectomy and decreased for pneumonectomy. The 30- and 90-day mortality and length of stay improved for lobectomy and esophagectomy over the study period, as did 90-day mortality for pneumonectomy. However, the interrupted time series analysis did not demonstrate any statistically significant effect of regionalization on these outcomes, separate from preexisting trends. CONCLUSIONS: Consistent improvements in mortality and length of stay in thoracic surgical oncology occurred on a provincial level between 2003 and 2020, although this analysis does not attribute these improvements to implementation of Thoracic Surgical Oncology Standards including regionalization.
引用
- Crosina J, Wright F, Irish J, et al. Long-Term Impact of Regionalization of Thoracic Oncology Surgery. Ann Thorac Surg. 2024. PMID: 39442904. doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2024.10.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。