指南与共识瓣膜外科

相同证据不同推荐:跨大西洋瓣膜性心脏病指南方法学评估

Same evidence different recommendations: a methodological assessment of transatlantic guidelines for the management of valvular heart disease.
指南 / 共识 · Eur J Cardiothorac Surg · 2024-01-01

该研究深入分析ACC/AHA与ESC/EACTS瓣膜性心脏病指南制定方法,以美国医学研究所标准为基准评估。发现两份指南在写作委员会构成、证据评价、利益冲突管理和投票流程上存在显著差异,且均偏离医学研究所标准,导致治疗推荐不同,例如ESC/EACTS推荐机械主动脉瓣的年龄界值为60岁以下而ACC/AHA为50岁以下。

要点

  • ACC/AHA与ESC/EACTS瓣膜病指南在制定方法学上存在实质性差异。
  • 两份指南在文献回顾和证据分级等关键领域均偏离医学研究所标准。
  • 方法学差异导致治疗推荐不同,如机械主动脉瓣年龄界值ESC/EACTS为60岁以下、ACC/AHA为50岁以下。

核心结论

  • 临床实践指南制定方法学的差异导致了不同的治疗推荐,可能显著影响全球实践模式。
  • 关键流程的标准化对于提高临床实践指南的一致性和可信度至关重要,最终改善医疗质量、减少变异性并增强对现代医学的信任。

研究设计与样本

  • 对ACC/AHA与ESC/EACTS瓣膜性心脏病指南制定方法进行深入分析,并以美国医学研究所提出的标准为基准进行评价。

主要发现

  • 两份指南在写作委员会构成、证据评价、利益冲突管理和投票流程等制定过程方法学上存在显著差异。
  • 尽管两份指南方法学彼此不同,但均在文献回顾和证据分级等关键领域明显偏离医学研究所标准。
  • 这些双重差异可能影响了治疗推荐的分歧。

关键数值与推荐

  • ESC/EACTS推荐对不适合二尖瓣手术的慢性重度二尖瓣反流患者行经导管缘对缘修复,而ACC/AHA推荐根据解剖情况行经导管缘对缘修复,不考虑手术风险。
  • ESC/EACTS指南推荐60岁以下患者使用机械主动脉瓣,而ACC/AHA指南推荐50岁以下患者使用。
  • ACC/AHA与ESC/EACTS指南对主动脉瓣置换选择外科手术而非经导管主动脉瓣置换的年龄界值不同,分别为<65岁和<75岁。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to identify methodological variations leading to varied recommendations between the American College of Cardiology (ACC)/American Heart Association (AHA) and the European Society of Cardiology (ESC)/European Association for Cardio-Thoracic Surgery (EACTS) valvular heart disease guidelines and to suggest foundational steps towards standardizing guideline development. METHODS: An in-depth analysis was conducted to evaluate the methodologies used in developing the transatlantic guidelines for managing valvular heart disease. The evaluation was benchmarked against the standards proposed by the Institute of Medicine. RESULTS: Substantial discrepancies were noted in the methodologies utilized in development processes, including Writing Committee composition, evidence evaluation, conflict of interest management and voting processes. Furthermore, despite their mutual differences, both methodologies demonstrate notable deviations from the Institute of Medicine standards in several essential areas, including literature review and evidence grading. These dual variances likely influenced divergent treatment recommendations. For example, the ESC/EACTS recommends transcatheter edge-to-edge repair for patients with chronic severe mitral regurgitation ineligible for mitral valve surgery, while the ACC/AHA recommends transcatheter edge-to-edge repair based on anatomy, regardless of surgical risk. ESC/EACTS guidelines recommend a mechanical aortic prosthesis for patients under 60, while ACC/AHA guidelines recommend it for patients under 50. Notably, the ACC/AHA and ESC/EACTS guidelines have differing age cut-offs for surgical over transcatheter aortic valve replacement (<65 and <75 years, respectively). CONCLUSIONS: Variations in methodologies for developing clinical practice guidelines have resulted in different treatment recommendations that may significantly impact global practice patterns. Standardization of essential processes is vital to increase the uniformity and credibility of clinical practice guidelines, ultimately improving healthcare quality, reducing variability and enhancing trust in modern medicine.

来源:Eur J Cardiothorac Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Milojevic M, Sousa-Uva M, Marin-Cuartas M, et al. Same evidence different recommendations: a methodological assessment of transatlantic guidelines for the management of valvular heart disease. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2024. PMID: 38733575. doi:10.1093/ejcts/ezae184

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。