先天性心脏病手术机器学习衍生的深度基准分析工具
该研究基于欧洲先天性心脏病外科医师协会数据库1989年至2022年间172,888例先天性心脏病手术,构建最优分类树模型预测住院死亡(AUC 0.866)、延长机械通气时间(AUC 0.851)和住院时长(AUC 0.818),建立“虚拟医院”基准。146个中心中,20.5%的医院调整后住院死亡表现优于基准,20.5%低于基准。在线交互工具可自动分析14个医院特异性患者队列。
要点
- 最优分类树模型预测住院死亡AUC为0.866,延长机械通气AUC为0.851,住院时长AUC为0.818。
- 146个参与中心中,20.5%调整后住院死亡表现优于基准,20.5%低于基准(<90% CI)。
- 在线工具可自动揭示14个医院特异性患者队列并评估表现优劣。
核心结论
- 基于机器学习的最优分类树基准分析可自动评估先天性心脏病手术后医院特异性病例调整表现,不仅整体而且可按相似风险患者队列评估。
- 该工具用于医院自我评估,用户可访问的在线平台尤其便利。
研究设计与样本
- 分析欧洲先天性心脏病外科医师协会先天性心脏病数据库1989年至2022年间在欧洲中心进行的172,888例先天性心脏病手术。
- 构建最优分类树(决策树)模型预测住院死亡、术后延长机械通气时间或住院时长,建立反映所有参与医院整体表现的病例调整基准,称为“虚拟医院”。
- 对虚拟医院汇总数据进行最优分类树分析,得出个体医院自身特定病例组合的预测预期结局(汇总及风险匹配患者队列),可在线获取。
主要发现
- 原始平均率:住院死亡4.9%,机械通气支持时间14.5%,住院时长15.0%。
- 146个参与中心中,与各医院整体病例调整预测住院死亡基准相比,20.5%表现优于基准(<90% CI),20.5%表现低于基准。
- 基于最优分类树分析的交互工具自动揭示14个医院特异性患者队列,同时评估表现优劣,并支持对任意选择时间段的队列分层进一步分析。
关键数值与推荐
- 最优分类树模型预测住院死亡AUC为0.866。
- 最优分类树模型预测延长术后机械通气支持时间AUC为0.851。
- 最优分类树模型预测住院时长AUC为0.818。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: We previously showed that machine learning-based methodologies of optimal classification trees (OCTs) can accurately predict risk after congenital heart surgery and assess case-mix-adjusted performance after benchmark procedures. We extend this methodology to provide interpretable, easily accessible, and actionable hospital performance analysis across all procedures. METHODS: The European Congenital Heart Surgeons Association Congenital Cardiac Database data subset of 172,888 congenital cardiac surgical procedures performed in European centers between 1989 and 2022 was analyzed. OCT models (decision trees) were built predicting hospital mortality (area under the curve [AUC], 0.866), prolonged postoperative mechanical ventilatory support time (AUC, 0.851), or hospital length of stay (AUC, 0.818), thereby establishing case-adjusted benchmarking standards reflecting the overall performance of all participating hospitals, designated as the "virtual hospital." OCT analysis of virtual hospital aggregate data yielded predicted expected outcomes (both aggregate and for risk-matched patient cohorts) for the individual hospital's own specific case-mix, readily available on-line. RESULTS: Raw average rates were hospital mortality, 4.9%; mechanical ventilatory support time, 14.5%; and length of stay, 15.0%. Of 146 participating centers, compared with each hospital's overall case-adjusted predicted hospital mortality benchmark, 20.5% statistically (<90% CI) overperformed and 20.5% underperformed. An interactive tool based on the OCT analysis automatically reveals 14 hospital-specific patient cohorts, simultaneously assessing overperformance or underperformance, and enabling further analysis of cohort strata in any chosen time frame. CONCLUSIONS: Machine learning-based OCT benchmarking analysis provides automatic assessment of hospital-specific case-adjusted performance after congenital heart surgery, not only overall but importantly, also by similar risk patient cohorts. This is a tool for hospital self-assessment, particularly facilitated by the user-accessible online-platform.
引用
- Sarris GE, Zhuo D, Mingardi L, et al. Congenital Heart Surgery Machine Learning-Derived In-Depth Benchmarking Tool. Ann Thorac Surg. 2023. PMID: 38065331. doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2023.10.034
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。