食管切除术后食管旁疝:观察等待是否安全?
该研究回顾了2006至2021年在克利夫兰诊所接受食管切除术的1214例患者,评估食管旁疝的发生率、诊断时机及无症状患者观察等待的结果。食管旁疝3年患病率3.3%、10年7.7%,19%出现症状,4例择期修补,无症状疝无急诊干预。作者认为对无症状食管旁疝可考虑观察等待,持续症状者择期修补。
要点
- 食管旁疝3年患病率3.3%,10年7.7%,风险随时间增加
- 无症状食管旁疝未发生需急诊干预的急性并发症
- 19%患者出现症状,4例择期修补,2例等待修补
核心结论
- 食管旁疝风险随时间增加,长期症状监测是合理的。
- 无症状食管旁疝导致的急诊并发症罕见。
- 作者认为对无症状食管旁疝可考虑观察等待,持续症状者考虑择期修补。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,2006至2021年克利夫兰诊所1214例食管切除重建患者,复习CT识别食管旁疝,查阅病历了解诊断时机、疝特征、症状、并发症和处理。
- 期间无症状食管旁疝患者通常非手术治疗。
主要发现
- 37例患者发现食管旁疝,其中31例(84%)术前存在食管裂孔疝。
- 21例疝(57%)含结肠,7例(19%)含胰腺,9例(24%)含多个器官。
- 食管旁疝估计患病率3年时为3.3%,10年时为7.7%。
- 7例(19%)有症状,其中4例择期修补,2例目前等待修补。
- 无患者发生需急诊干预的急性并发症。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为对无症状食管旁疝可考虑观察等待,对持续症状者考虑择期修补。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: We hypothesized that emergency complications related to asymptomatic paraconduit hernias may occur less often than generally believed. Therefore, we assessed the occurrence and timing of paraconduit hernia diagnosis after esophagectomy, as well as outcomes of these asymptomatic patients managed with a watch-and-wait approach. METHODS: From 2006 to 2021, 1214 patients underwent esophagectomy with reconstruction at the Cleveland Clinic. Among these patients, computed tomography scans were reviewed to identify paraconduit hernias. Medical records were reviewed for timing of hernia diagnosis, hernia characteristics, and patient symptoms, complications, and management. During this period, patients with asymptomatic paraconduit hernias were typically managed nonoperatively. RESULTS: Paraconduit hernias were identified in 37 patients. Of these, 31 (84%) had a pre-esophagectomy hiatal hernia. Twenty-one hernias (57%) contained colon, 7 hernias (19%) contained pancreas, and 9 hernias (24%) contained multiple organs. Estimated prevalence of paraconduit hernia was 3.3% at 3 years and 7.7% at 10 years. Seven patients (19%) had symptoms, 4 of whom were repaired electively, with 2 currently awaiting repairs. No patient with a paraconduit hernia experienced an acute complication that required emergency intervention. CONCLUSIONS: The risk of paraconduit hernia increases with time, suggesting that long-term symptom surveillance is reasonable. Emergency complications as a result of asymptomatic paraconduit hernias are rare. A small number of patients will experience hernia-related symptoms, sometimes years after hernia diagnosis. Our findings suggest that observation of asymptomatic paraconduit hernias (watch and wait) may be considered, with repair considered electively in patients with persistent symptoms.
引用
- Barron JO, Ramji S, Nemoyer R, et al. Paraconduit hernia following esophagectomy: Is it safe to watch and wait? J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2023. PMID: 37673124. doi:10.1016/j.jtcvs.2023.08.041
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。