文献速递先天性心脏病外科

同类比较:基于常见先天性心脏病手术的先天性心脏病手术结果公开报告探索

Comparing apples to apples: Exploring public reporting of congenital cardiac surgery outcomes based on common congenital heart operations.
PubMed 文献 · J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg · 2023-09-07

该研究选取19种常见先天性心脏病手术,建立严格纳入/排除标准的诊断/手术队列,收集9个中心2016年1月1日至2021年12月31日连续合格患者数据,汇总未调整手术死亡率和住院时长并按中心分层。共纳入8572例,各队列例数从73例到1224例不等,总体死亡率从房间隔缺损修补的0%到杂交一期手术的28.4%,不同中心间病例组合和死亡率存在显著异质性。作者认为在明确定义的诊断/手术队列内报告机构病例量和结果可帮助中心进行基准比较、了解死亡率趋势并指导质量改进,公开此类报告可为家长提供信息。

要点

  • 19种常见先天性心脏病手术队列例数从73例到1224例不等。
  • 总体未调整死亡率从房间隔缺损修补的0%到杂交一期手术的28.4%。
  • 不同中心间病例组合和死亡率存在显著异质性,如Norwood手术死亡率5.3%-25%。

核心结论

  • 在明确定义的诊断/手术队列内报告机构病例量和结果可帮助中心进行基准比较、了解死亡率趋势并指导质量改进。
  • 公开此类报告可为家长提供机构病例量和结果信息,并使其更好地了解各项目在特定先天性心脏缺陷手术方面的经验。

研究设计与样本

  • 选取19种常见先天性心脏病手术,从房间隔缺损修补到Norwood手术,涵盖不同复杂度。
  • 采用严格纳入/排除标准建立19个明确定义的诊断/手术队列。
  • 收集9个中心2016年1月1日至2021年12月31日连续合格患者的术前、手术和术后数据。
  • 汇总各队列未调整手术死亡率和住院时长,总体汇总并按中心分层。

主要发现

  • 共纳入8572例合格病例,19个诊断/手术队列例数从73例(既往姑息术后法洛四联症修补)到1224例(孤立性室间隔缺损修补)不等。
  • 总体未调整死亡率从房间隔缺损修补的0%到杂交一期手术的28.4%。
  • 不同中心间不同诊断/手术队列的病例组合和死亡率存在显著异质性,例如动脉调转术/室间隔缺损修补 n=7-42、死亡率0%-7.4%;Norwood手术 n=16-122、死亡率5.3%-25%。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,在明确定义的诊断/手术队列内报告机构病例量和结果可帮助中心进行基准比较、了解死亡率趋势并指导质量改进。
  • 作者认为,公开此类报告可为家长提供机构病例量和结果信息,并使其更好地了解各项目在特定先天性心脏缺陷手术方面的经验。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: We sought to simplify reporting of outcomes in congenital heart surgery that compares well-defined patient groups and accommodates multiple stakeholder needs while being easily understandable. METHODS: We selected 19 commonly performed congenital heart surgeries ranging in complexity from repair of atrial septal defects to the Norwood procedure. Strict inclusion/exclusion criteria ensured the creation of 19 well-defined diagnosis/procedure cohorts. Preoperative, procedural, and postoperative data were collected for consecutive eligible patients from 9 centers between January 1, 2016, and December 31, 2021. Unadjusted operative mortality rates and hospital length of stay for each of the 19 diagnosis/procedure cohorts were summarized in aggregate and stratified by each center. RESULTS: Of 8572 eligible cases included, numbers in the 19 diagnosis/procedure cohorts ranged from 73 for tetralogy of Fallot repair after previous palliation to 1224 for ventricular septal defect (VSD) repair for isolated VSD. In aggregate, the unadjusted mortality ranged from 0% for atrial septal defect repair to 28.4% for hybrid stage I. There was significant heterogeneity in case mix and mortality for different diagnosis/procedure cohorts across centers (eg, arterial switch operation/VSD, n = 7-42, mortality 0%-7.4%; Norwood procedure, n = 16-122, mortality 5.3%-25%). CONCLUSIONS: Reporting of institutional case volumes and outcomes within well-defined diagnosis/procedure cohorts can enable centers to benchmark outcomes, understand trends in mortality, and direct quality improvement. When made public, this type of report could provide parents with information on institutional volumes and outcomes and allow them to better understand the experience of each program with operations for specific congenital heart defects.

来源:J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Nathan M, Gauvreau K, White O, et al. Comparing apples to apples: Exploring public reporting of congenital cardiac surgery outcomes based on common congenital heart operations. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2023. PMID: 37689234. doi:10.1016/j.jtcvs.2023.08.052

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。