美国机器人胸外科医师的国家学习曲线:量化手术经验对效率和生产力提升的影响
研究基于My Intuitive应用提取2021至2022年870名外科医师完成的56,668例机器人肺切除术数据,分析控制台时间与每小时生产力(工作相对价值单位/小时)。结果显示所有机器人手术的平均控制台时间随累计病例经验增加而改善(P=0.003),肺段切除术和胸腺切除术初始学习曲线最陡,熟练医师较新手医师平均控制台时间分别缩短33%和34%。
要点
- 熟练医师(51-100例)较新手医师(1-10例)肺段切除术和胸腺切除术平均控制台时间分别缩短33%和34%。
- 熟练医师每小时生产力提升从肺叶切除术的11.4工作相对价值单位/小时(+26%)到肺段切除术的17.0工作相对价值单位/小时(+50%)。
- 专家级别(101例以上)肺叶切除术和食管切除术平均控制台时间继续显著下降(分别-23%和-18%),楔形切除术仅-1%(P=0.003)。
核心结论
- 美国机器人胸外科医师的总学习曲线因手术类型而异,肺叶切除术和食管切除术在超过100例后效率持续改善。
- 经验增长带来的效率提升转化为显著的生产力增益。
研究设计与样本
- 从My Intuitive应用(版本1.7.0)提取全国平均控制台时间与累计病例数的关系。
- 回顾2021年至2022年间870名外科医师完成的56,668例机器人肺切除术的Intuitive da Vinci机器人系统数据。
- 使用线性回归模型分析控制台时间和每小时生产力(工作相对价值单位/小时)。
主要发现
- 所有机器人手术的平均控制台时间随累计病例经验增加而改善(P=0.003)。
- 熟练医师(51-100例)较新手医师(1-10例)肺段切除术和胸腺切除术平均控制台时间分别缩短33%和34%。
- 熟练医师每小时生产力提升从肺叶切除术的11.4工作相对价值单位/小时(+26%)到肺段切除术的17.0工作相对价值单位/小时(+50%)。
- 专家级别(101例以上)食管切除术和肺叶切除术平均控制台时间继续显著下降(分别-18%和-23%),楔形切除术仅-1%(P=0.003)。
- 专家级别肺叶切除术和食管切除术工作相对价值单位/小时分别提升50%和40%。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: This study aims to characterize the aggregate learning curves of US surgeons for robotic thoracic procedures and to quantify the impact on productivity. METHODS: National average console times relative to cumulative case number were extracted from the My Intuitive application (Version 1.7.0). Intuitive da Vinci robotic system data for 56,668 lung resections performed by 870 individual surgeons between 2021 and 2022 were reviewed. Console time and hourly productivity (work relative value units/hour) were analyzed using linear regression models. RESULTS: Average console times improved for all robotic procedures with cumulative case experience (P = .003). Segmentectomy and thymectomy had the steepest initial learning curves with a 33% and 34% reduction of the average console time for proficient (51-100 cases) relative to novice surgeons (1-10 cases), respectively. The hourly productivity increase for proficient surgeons ranged from 11.4 work relative value units/hour (+26%) for lobectomy to 17.0 work relative value units/hour (+50%) for segmentectomy. At the expert level (101+ cases), average console times continued to decrease significantly for esophagectomy (-18%) and lobectomy (-23%), but only minimally for wedge resections (-1%) (P = .003). The work relative value units/hour increase at the expert level reached 50% for lobectomy and 40% for esophagectomy. Surgeon experience level, dual console use, system model, and robotic stapler use were factors independently associated with console time for robotic lobectomy. CONCLUSIONS: The aggregate learning curve for robotic thoracic surgeons in the United States varies significantly by procedure type and demonstrate continued improvements in efficiency beyond 100 cases for lobectomy and esophagectomy. Improvements in efficiency with growing experiences translate to substantial productivity gains.
引用
- Vijayakumar A, Abdel-Rasoul M, Hekmat R, et al. National learning curves among robotic thoracic surgeons in the United States: Quantifying the impact of procedural experience on efficiency and productivity gains. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2023. PMID: 37562675. doi:10.1016/j.jtcvs.2023.07.051
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。