开放与血管内胸腹主动脉修复术中的神经监测实践——一项基于国际专家的改良德尔菲共识研究
主动脉协会开展国际在线调查并基于首轮结果形成18个德尔菲共识问题,共56名医师完成调查。开放胸腹主动脉修复术中至少使用一种神经监测或保护措施,脑脊液引流使用率97.9%;血管内修复中53个中心有3个未使用任何神经监测或保护,脑脊液引流使用率92.5%。共识认为保护脊髓以避免脊髓损伤在开放修复中获广泛共识,血管内修复中使用较少但应考虑,尤其需广泛覆盖胸腹主动脉的患者。
要点
- 开放胸腹主动脉修复术中至少使用一种神经监测或保护措施,脑脊液引流使用率97.9%。
- 血管内胸腹主动脉修复中53个中心有3个未使用任何神经监测或保护,脑脊液引流使用率92.5%。
- 共识认为血管内修复中这些措施使用较少但应考虑,尤其需广泛覆盖胸腹主动脉的患者。
核心结论
- 调查与德尔菲共识结果显示,开放胸腹主动脉修复术中保护脊髓以避免脊髓损伤的重要性获得广泛共识。
- 这些措施在血管内胸腹主动脉修复中使用较少,但应考虑,尤其对需要广泛覆盖胸腹主动脉的患者。
研究设计与样本
- 主动脉协会开展关于开放与血管内胸腹主动脉修复中神经监测的国际在线调查。
- 首轮由专家小组制定调查问卷,基于首轮回答形成18个德尔菲共识问题。
- 共56名医师完成调查,其中45名同时开展开放与血管内胸腹主动脉修复,3名仅开展开放修复,8名仅开展血管内修复。
主要发现
- 开放胸腹主动脉手术中至少使用一种神经监测或保护措施;脑脊液引流使用率97.9%,近红外光谱70.8%,运动诱发电位或体感诱发电位60.4%。
- 血管内胸腹主动脉修复中53个中心有3个未使用任何形式的神经监测或保护;脑脊液引流使用率92.5%,脑或椎旁近红外光谱35.8%,运动诱发电位或体感诱发电位24.5%。
- 脑脊液引流和神经监测的使用因胸腹主动脉修复范围不同而变化。
关键数值与推荐
- 开放胸腹主动脉修复中脑脊液引流使用率97.9%。
- 开放胸腹主动脉修复中近红外光谱使用率70.8%。
- 开放胸腹主动脉修复中运动诱发电位或体感诱发电位使用率60.4%。
- 血管内胸腹主动脉修复中脑脊液引流使用率92.5%,脑或椎旁近红外光谱35.8%,运动诱发电位或体感诱发电位24.5%。
- 血管内胸腹主动脉修复中53个中心有3个未使用任何形式的神经监测或保护。
临床怎么用
- 开放胸腹主动脉修复中至少使用一种神经监测或保护措施。
- 血管内胸腹主动脉修复中这些措施使用较少但应考虑,尤其对需要广泛覆盖胸腹主动脉的患者。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Spinal cord injury is detrimental for patients undergoing open or endovascular thoracoabdominal aortic aneurysm (TAAA) repair. The aim of this survey and of the modified Delphi consensus was to gather information on current practices and standards in neuroprotection in patients undergoing open and endovascular TAAA. METHODS: The Aortic Association conducted an international online survey on neuromonitoring in open and endovascular TAAA repair. In a first round an expert panel put together a survey on different aspects of neuromonitoring. Based on the answers from the first round of the survey, 18 Delphi consensus questions were formulated. RESULTS: A total of 56 physicians completed the survey. Of these, 45 perform open and endovascular TAAA repair, 3 do open TAAA repair and 8 do endovascular TAAA repair. At least 1 neuromonitoring or protection modality is utilized during open TAAA surgery. Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) drainage was used in 97.9%, near infrared spectroscopy in 70.8% and motor evoked potentials or somatosensory evoked potentials in 60.4%. Three of 53 centres do not utilize any form of neuromonitoring or protection during endovascular TAAA repair: 92.5% use CSF drainage; 35.8%, cerebral or paravertebral near infrared spectroscopy; and 24.5% motor evoked potentials or somatosensory evoked potentials. The utilization of CSF drainage and neuromonitoring varies depending on the extent of the TAAA repair. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this survey and of the Delphi consensus show that there is broad consensus on the importance of protecting the spinal cord to avoid spinal cord injury in patients undergoing open TAAA repair. Those measures are less frequently utilized in patients undergoing endovascular TAAA repair but should be considered, especially in patients who require extensive coverage of the thoracoabdominal aorta.
引用
- Schachner T, Gottardi R, Schmidli J, et al. Practice of neuromonitoring in open and endovascular thoracoabdominal aortic repair-an international expert-based modified Delphi consensus study. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2023. PMID: 37252816. doi:10.1093/ejcts/ezad198
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。