改良冰冻象鼻术在急性I型夹层中可能优于局限性和扩展经典修复术
该研究比较了急性DeBakey I型夹层患者接受局限性、扩展经典或改良冰冻象鼻术(mFET)修复后的手术趋势、并发症、再干预和生存情况。在加权倾向匹配患者中,mFET修复的术后肾功能衰竭少于局限组,且7年生存率高于局限组;mFET修复便于血管内再干预。
要点
- mFET修复的术后肾功能衰竭发生率低于局限修复(12% vs 25%)。
- 局限修复的院内死亡率低于扩展经典修复(9.1% vs 19%)。
- mFET修复后7年生存率为89%,局限修复后为65%。
核心结论
- 在不增加院内死亡率或并发症、肾功能衰竭更少且中期生存有改善趋势的情况下,mFET可能优于局限性或扩展经典修复术治疗急性DeBakey I型夹层。
- mFET修复便于血管内再干预,可能减少未来侵入性再手术,值得继续研究。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析1978年1月1日至2018年1月1日在Cleveland Clinic因急性DeBakey I型夹层接受手术的879例患者。
- 修复方式包括局限于升主动脉/半弓(701.79%)、扩展经典修复(88.10%)或mFET(90.10%)。
- 采用加权倾向评分匹配建立可比组。
主要发现
- 在加权倾向匹配患者中,mFET修复的循环停止时间和术后并发症与局限修复相似,但术后肾功能衰竭在局限组高出一倍[25%(n=19)vs 12%(n=9),P=0.006]。
- 局限修复相比扩展经典修复观察到更低的院内死亡率[9.1%(n=7)vs 19%(n=16),P=0.03],但mFET修复后未见此差异[12%(n=9)vs 9.5%(n=8),P=0.6]。
- 扩展经典修复的早期死亡风险高于局限修复(P=0.0005),而局限修复与mFET修复组间无差异(P=0.9)。
- mFET修复后7年生存率为89%,局限修复后为65%。
- 局限或扩展经典修复后的再干预多采用开放再干预,而mFET修复后的所有再干预均通过血管内完成。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,在不增加院内死亡率或并发症、肾功能衰竭更少且中期生存有改善趋势的情况下,mFET可能优于局限性或扩展经典修复术治疗急性DeBakey I型夹层。
- 作者指出,mFET修复便于血管内再干预,可能减少未来侵入性再手术,并值得继续研究。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: A better surgical approach for acute DeBakey type I dissection has been sought for decades. We compare operative trends, complications, reinterventions and survival after limited versus extended-classic versus modified frozen elephant trunk (mFET) repair for this condition. METHODS: From 1 January 1978 to 1 January 2018, 879 patients underwent surgery for acute DeBakey type I dissection at Cleveland Clinic. Repairs were limited to the ascending aorta/hemiarch (701.79%) or extended through the arch [extended classic (88.10%) or mFET (90.10%)]. Weighted propensity score matched established comparable groups. RESULTS: Among weighted propensity-matched patients, mFET repair had similar circulatory arrest times and postoperative complications to limited repair, except for postoperative renal failure, which was twice as high in the limited group [25% (n = 19) vs 12% (n = 9), P = 0.006]. Lower in-hospital mortality was observed following limited compared to extended-classic repair [9.1% (n = 7) vs 19% (n = 16), P = 0.03], but not after mFET repair [12% (n = 9) vs 9.5% (n = 8), P = 0.6]. Extended-classic repair had higher risk of early death than limited repair (P = 0.0005) with no difference between limited and mFET repair groups (P = 0.9); 7-year survival following mFET repair was 89% compared to 65% after limited repair. Most reinterventions following limited or extended-classic repair underwent open reintervention. All reinterventions following mFET repair were completed endovascularly. CONCLUSIONS: Without increasing in-hospital mortality or complications, less renal failure and a trend towards improved intermediate survival, mFET may be superior to limited or extended-classic repair for acute DeBakey type I dissections. mFET repair facilitates endovascular reintervention, potentially reducing future invasive reoperations and warranting continued study.
引用
- Roselli EE, Kramer B, Germano E, et al. The modified frozen elephant trunk may outperform limited and extended-classic repair in acute type I dissection. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2023. PMID: 37018150. doi:10.1093/ejcts/ezad122
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。