使用术后机械通气质量指标衡量心脏重症监护病房绩效
该观察性分析纳入26个儿科心脏重症监护联盟中心的16,848例先天性心脏病术后机械通气住院患儿,建立多变量模型调整术前术后因素计算各CICU的观察值与预期值通气时长比,发现中心间调整后通气时长比在0.7至1.7间差异广泛,9个中心显著优于预期、10个显著差于预期,若干组织特征与较短调整后通气时长相关。
要点
- 26个中心调整后通气时长比范围0.7至1.7,9个中心显著优于预期、10个显著差于预期。
- 重症或麻醉培训主治医师混合 staffing(60%-90%)、较低平均主治医师与患者比、CICU日均 occupancy 80%至90%、更高护士 staffing 比与经验与较短调整后通气时长相关。
- 术后机械通气时长可作为CICU绩效指标,中心间差异广泛且部分组织因素可能可改变。
核心结论
- 儿科心脏重症监护联盟中心间先心病术后机械通气时长绩效差异广泛。
- 若干可能可改变的组织因素与该指标相关。
- 这些发现可推动 outlier 医院改善通气时长。
研究设计与样本
- 观察性分析,纳入26个儿科心脏重症监护联盟CICU的16,848例手术住院患儿,均为从手术室转入时接受有创通气者。
- 拟合多变量模型预测术后机械通气时长,调整术前和术后因素以衡量CICU绩效并考虑术后疾病严重程度。
- 计算各CICU的观察值与预期值(调整后)通气时长比,描述中心间变异,基于偏差校正 bootstrap 95%CI 识别 outlier。
- 将组织特征作为自变量加入模型,探索其与患者层面调整后通气时长的关联。
主要发现
- 各CICU调整后通气时长比范围0.7至1.7。
- 26个CICU中9个通气时长统计学显著优于预期,10个显著差于预期。
- 与较短调整后通气时长相关的组织特征包括:由重症或麻醉培训主治医师混合 staffing(60%-90%)、较低平均主治医师与患者比、CICU日均 occupancy 80%至90%、更高护士 staffing 比与经验。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Safely minimizing postoperative mechanical ventilation duration after congenital heart surgery could be a cardiac intensive care unit (CICU) quality measure. We aimed to measure CICU performance using duration of postoperative mechanical ventilation and identify organizational factors associated with this metric. METHODS: Observational analysis of 16,848 surgical hospitalizations of patients invasively ventilated on admission from the operating room from 26 Pediatric Cardiac Critical Care Consortium CICUs. We fitted a multivariable model to predict duration of postoperative mechanical ventilation adjusting for pre- and postoperative factors to measure CICU performance accounting for postoperative illness severity. We used our model to calculate observed-to-expected (adjusted) ventilation duration ratios for each CICU, describe variation across CICUs, and characterize outliers based on bias-corrected bootstrap 95% CIs. We explored associations between organizational characteristics and patient-level adjusted ventilation duration by adding these as independent variables to the model. RESULTS: We observed wide variation across CICUs in adjusted ventilation duration ratios, ranging from 0.7 to 1.7. Nine of 26 CICUs had statistically better than expected ventilation duration, while 10 were significantly worse than expected. Organizational characteristics associated with shorter adjusted ventilation duration included mixed (60%-90%) staffing by critical care or anesthesia-trained attendings, lower average attending-to-patient ratio, average CICU daily occupancy 80% to 90%, and greater nurse staffing ratios and experience. CONCLUSIONS: CICU performance in postoperative duration of mechanical ventilation varies widely across Pediatric Cardiac Critical Care Consortium centers. Several potentially modifiable organizational factors are associated with this metric. Taken together, these findings could spur efforts to improve ventilation duration at outlier hospitals.
引用
- Werho DK, Fisk A, Yeh J, et al. Measuring Critical Care Unit Performance Using a Postoperative Mechanical Ventilation Quality Metric. Ann Thorac Surg. 2022. PMID: 36470563. doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2022.11.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。