多中心倾向性评分匹配分析比较主动脉根部动脉瘤保留瓣膜与瓣膜置换策略:来自AVIATOR数据库的洞见
本研究基于AVIATOR数据库,比较保留瓣膜根部置换(VSRR)与复合瓣膜-血管 conduit 主动脉根部置换(CVG-ARR)在主动脉根部动脉瘤(伴或不伴瓣膜关闭不全、无瓣膜狭窄)患者中的结局。倾向性评分按3:1匹配218例CVG-ARR与654例VSRR后,VSRR组5年生存率95.4%高于CVG-ARR组85.4%(P=0.002),5年免于再干预率两组无显著差异(96.8% vs 95.4%,P=0.98),CVG-ARR组血栓栓塞、心内膜炎和出血事件更多(P=0.02)。
要点
- 匹配后VSRR组5年生存率95.4%(95%CI 94-97%)高于CVG-ARR组85.4%(95%CI 82-92%),P=0.002。
- 5年免于再干预率VSRR组96.8%(95%CI 95-98%)与CVG-ARR组95.4%(95%CI 91-99%)无显著差异,P=0.98。
- CVG-ARR组血栓栓塞、心内膜炎和出血事件多于VSRR组,P=0.02。
核心结论
- 在主动脉根部动脉瘤(伴或不伴瓣膜关闭不全、无瓣膜狭窄)患者中,保留瓣膜根部置换术后结果良好。
- 与复合瓣膜-血管 conduit 主动脉根部置换相比,保留瓣膜根部置换生存更好且瓣膜相关事件更少。
- 作者认为只要耐久修复可行,应考虑保留瓣膜手术;并主张在经验丰富的中心即使更复杂的病例也采用保留瓣膜策略。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心倾向性评分匹配分析,基于AVIATOR数据库。
- VSRR手术2005例,CVG-ARR手术218例。
- 排除标准包括主动脉夹层、心内膜炎和瓣膜狭窄。
- 采用3:1比例倾向性评分匹配比较VSRR(再植入33%、重塑67%)与CVG-ARR。
- 匹配218例CVG-ARR与654例VSRR,中位年龄56.0岁,两组中位随访均为4年(四分位距1-5年)。
主要发现
- 早期死亡率VSRR组1.1% vs CVG-ARR组2.3%。
- 5年生存率VSRR组95.4%(95%CI 94-97%)vs CVG-ARR组85.4%(95%CI 82-92%),P=0.002。
- 5年免于再干预率VSRR组96.8%(95%CI 95-98%)vs CVG-ARR组95.4%(95%CI 91-99%),P=0.98。
- CVG-ARR组血栓栓塞、心内膜炎和出血事件多于VSRR组,P=0.02。
关键数值与推荐
- 匹配后VSRR组654例,CVG-ARR组218例(3:1匹配)。
- 5年生存率VSRR组95.4%(95%CI 94-97%)vs CVG-ARR组85.4%(95%CI 82-92%),P=0.002。
- 5年免于再干预率VSRR组96.8%(95%CI 95-98%)vs CVG-ARR组95.4%(95%CI 91-99%),P=0.98。
- 瓣膜相关事件(血栓栓塞、心内膜炎、出血)CVG-ARR组多于VSRR组,P=0.02。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为只要耐久修复可行,应考虑保留瓣膜手术。
- 作者主张在经验丰富的中心即使更复杂的病例也采用保留瓣膜策略。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Our goal was to evaluate the outcome of valve-sparing root replacement (VSRR) and to compare the outcomes to those of patients having composite valve-graft conduit aortic root replacement (CVG-ARR) in a cohort of patients with aortic root aneurysm ± valve insufficiency, without valvular stenosis. Although valve-sparing procedures are preferable in young patients, there is a lack of comparative data in comparable patients. METHODS: The VSRR procedures were performed in 2005 patients, and 218 patients underwent a CVG-ARR procedure. Exclusion criteria included aortic dissection, endocarditis and valvular stenosis. Propensity score matching (3:1 ratio) was applied to compare VSRR (reimplantation 33% and remodelling 67%) and CVG-ARR. RESULTS: We matched 218 patients with CVG-ARR to 654 patients with VSRR (median age, 56.0; median follow-up was 4 years in both groups; interquartile range 1-5 years). Early mortality was 1.1% of those who had VSRR versus 2.3% in those who had CVG-ARR. Survival was 95.4% [95% confidence interval (CI) 94-97%] at 5 years in patients who had VSRR versus 85.4% (95% CI 82-92%) in those who had CVG-ARR; P = 0.002. Freedom from reintervention at 5 years was 96.8% (95% CI 95-98%) with VSRR and 95.4% (95% CI 91-99%) with CVG-ARR (P = 0.98). Additionally, there were more thromboembolic, endocarditis and bleeding events in the patients who had CVG-ARR (P = 0.02). CONCLUSIONS: This multicentre study shows excellent results after valve-sparing root replacement in patients with an ascending aortic aneurysm with or without valve insufficiency. Compared to composite valve-graft aortic root replacement, survival is better and valve-related events are fewer. Consequently, valve-sparing procedures should be considered whenever a durable repair is feasible. We advocate a valve-sparing strategy even in more complex cases when performed in experienced centres.
引用
- Arabkhani B, Klautz RJM, de Heer F, et al. A multicentre, propensity score matched analysis comparing a valve-sparing approach to valve replacement in aortic root aneurysm: Insight from the AVIATOR database. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2023. PMID: 36308450. doi:10.1093/ejcts/ezac514
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。