电视辅助胸腔镜手术中的左上肺叶挑战——使用复合评分改进模拟肺叶切除术的评估
本研究将两项既往研究中的标准化客观评估(时间、出血、操作经济性)与主观专家评分相结合,基于123例虚拟现实电视辅助胸腔镜手术肺叶切除术,开发复合评分以评估手术能力。结果显示经验、肺叶和模拟器经验对4项评估有显著影响(P < 0.01),左上肺叶显著更难(P = 0.02),标准化模拟器指标联合标准化专家评分可靠性最高达0.92,包含1名专家评分者时复合评分及格线为0.33。结论认为联合模拟器指标与1或2名评分者可提高可靠性,可作为评估外科受训者的更客观方法。
要点
- 左上肺叶在模拟肺叶切除术中显著比其他肺叶更难(P = 0.02)。
- 标准化模拟器指标联合专家评分可靠性最高达0.92。
- 包含1名专家评分者时复合评分及格线为0.33。
核心结论
- 将模拟器指标与1或2名评分者结合可提高可靠性,可作为评估外科受训者的更客观方法。
- 复合评分可用于实施标准化且可行的模拟式掌握培训项目。
研究设计与样本
- 将来自2项既往研究的标准化客观评估(时间、出血、操作经济性)与主观专家评分相结合。
- 共纳入123例虚拟现实电视辅助胸腔镜手术肺叶切除术。
- 采用线性混合模型分析经验水平、肺叶和既往模拟操作次数对重复测量的影响。
- 使用Cronbach's alpha计算4项评估各自的可靠性,采用Nelder-Mead数值优化算法进行最优加权,采用对比组法确定复合评分的及格标准。
主要发现
- 在4项不同评估中,经验、肺叶和模拟器经验均存在显著效应(P < 0.01),但模拟尝试次数对出血无显著效应(P = 0.98)。
- 左上肺叶显著比其他肺叶更难(P = 0.02)。
- 将标准化模拟器指标与标准化专家评分相结合,可靠性最高可达0.92。
- 包含1名专家评分者时复合评分的及格/不及格水平为0.33。
关键数值与推荐
- 复合评分包含1名专家评分者时及格线为0.33。
- 标准化模拟器指标联合标准化专家评分可靠性最高为0.92。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为复合评分可用于实施标准化且可行的电视辅助胸腔镜手术肺叶切除术模拟式掌握培训项目。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: The aim of this study is to develop a reliable composite score based on simulator metrics to assess competency in virtual reality video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery lobectomy and explore the benefits of combining it with expert rater assessments. METHODS: Standardized objective assessments (time, bleeding, economy of movement) and subjective expert rater assessments from 2 previous studies were combined. A linear mixed model including experience level, lobe and the number of previous simulated procedures was applied for the repeated measurements. Reliability for each of the 4 assessments was calculated using Cronbach's alpha. The Nelder-Mead numerical optimization algorithm was used for optimal weighting of scores. A pass-fail standard for the composite score was determined using the contrasting groups' method. RESULTS: In total, 123 virtual reality video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery lobectomies were included. Across the 4 different assessments, there were significant effects (P < 0.01) of experience, lobe, and simulator experience, but not for simulator attempts on bleeding (P = 0.98). The left upper lobe was significantly more difficult compared to other lobes (P = 0.02). A maximum reliability of 0.92 could be achieved by combining the standardized simulator metrics with standardized expert rater scores. The pass/fail level for the composite score when including 1 expert rater was 0.33. CONCLUSIONS: Combining simulator metrics with 1 or 2 raters increases reliability and can serve as a more objective method for assessing surgical trainees. The composite score may be used to implement a standardized and feasible simulation-based mastery training program in video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery lobectomy.
引用
- Haidari TA, Bjerrum F, Grimstrup S, et al. The left upper lobe challenge in video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery-use of a composite score to improve the assessment of simulated lobectomy. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2022. PMID: 36111869. doi:10.1093/ejcts/ezac465
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。