上消化道疾病应用程序与医疗提供者对食管切除术后症状评估的一致性研究
本研究评估上消化道疾病(UDD)应用程序评分阈值的效标效度。2017年12月15日至2020年12月15日,59例食管切除术后患者使用UDD App并同时接受医疗提供者评估。结果显示吞咽困难(κ=0.52;P<.001)和反流(κ=0.42;P<.001)一致性中等,而倾倒相关低血糖(κ=0.03;P=.148)、胃肠道症状(κ=0.02;P=.256)和疼痛(κ=0.05;P<.184)一致性极低,提供者低估了患者报告的症状。
要点
- UDD App与提供者评估在吞咽困难和反流上一致性中等(κ分别为0.52和0.42;P<.001)。
- 倾倒相关低血糖、胃肠道症状和疼痛领域一致性极低(κ分别为0.03、0.02、0.05),提供者低估患者报告的问题。
- 未来需研究是否修订疼痛和倾倒领域的阈值或增加提供者教育。
核心结论
- UDD App评估与提供者评估在食管切除术后吞咽困难和反流上存在一致性,但倾倒相关症状和疼痛的评分不一致。
- 未来研究需确定是否修订疼痛和倾倒领域的阈值或是否需要额外提供者教育。
研究设计与样本
- 研究于2017年12月15日至2020年12月15日纳入食管切除术后患者,同时使用UDD App和提供者临床评估。
- UDD App包含67个问题,涵盖5个新领域,根据领域评分阈值将患者分为好、中、差三类。
- 提供者根据临床评估将患者分类,使用加权κ统计量确定一致性程度。
- 共59例患者纳入研究(76%男性;中位年龄63岁[四分位距57-72岁])。
- 提供者评估每例患者1至10次,中位时间为食管切除术后296.5天(四分位距50-975天)。
主要发现
- 吞咽困难的一致性为中等(κ=0.52;P<.001)。
- 反流的一致性为中等(κ=0.42;P<.001)。
- 倾倒相关低血糖的一致性极低(κ=0.03;P=.148)。
- 胃肠道症状的一致性极低(κ=0.02;P=.256)。
- 疼痛的一致性极低(κ=0.05;P<.184),提供者低估了患者报告的症状和问题。
局限性
- 未来研究需确定是否修订疼痛和倾倒领域的阈值或是否需要额外提供者教育。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The objective of this study was to assess the criterion validity of score thresholds for the Upper Digestive Disease (UDD) App. METHODS: From December 15, 2017, to December 15, 2020, patients presenting after esophagectomy were offered the UDD App concurrent with a provider visit. This tool consists of 67 questions including 5 novel domains. Score thresholds were used to assign patients to a good, moderate, or poor category on the basis of domain scores. Providers were given performance descriptions for each domain and asked to assign patients to a category on the basis of their clinical evaluation. The weighted κ statistic was used to determine the magnitude of agreement between classifications based on the patients' UDD App scores and the providers' clinical evaluation. RESULTS: Fifty-nine patients in the study (76% male; median age, 63 years [interquartile range, 57-72 years]) reported outcomes using the UDD App. Providers reviewed between 1 and 10 patients at a median time of 296.5 days (interquartile range, 50-975 days) after esophagectomy. The magnitude of agreement between patients and providers was moderate for dysphagia (κ = 0.52; P < .001) and reflux (κ = 0.42; P < .001). Dumping-related hypoglycemia (κ = 0.03; P = .148), gastrointestinal complaints (κ = 0.02; P = .256), and pain (κ = 0.05; P < .184) showed minimal agreement, with providers underestimating the symptoms and problems reported by patients in these domains. CONCLUSIONS: Although there was agreement between UDD App assessment and provider evaluation of dysphagia and reflux after esophagectomy, there was discordance of scoring for dumping-related symptoms and pain. Future research is needed to determine whether thresholds for pain and dumping domains need to be revised or whether additional provider education on performance descriptions is needed.
引用
- Traynor MD, Chlan LL, Wzientek C, et al. Agreement Between Upper Digestive Disease App and Provider Evaluation of Esophagectomy Symptoms in a Mobile App Tool. Ann Thorac Surg. 2022. PMID: 35988736. doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2022.06.060
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。