临时机械循环支持:装置、结局与未来方向
本文概述临时机械循环支持(tMCS)作为移植桥接策略的装置特性与局限,梳理装置支持后移植结局的演变,并比较各国心脏移植分配方案。作者提出指导供体分配系统下一轮迭代的关键原则,以平衡等待list死亡率与最佳移植后结局。
要点
- 全球多数器官分配系统优先分配tMCS支持患者,但缺乏tMCS桥接策略的严格标准。
- tMCS装置支持后的移植结局正在演变,需关注装置选择与等待时间的影响。
- 作者提出分配应基于计算评分、高危状态时限严格续期、细化持久机械支持及例外同行评审。
核心结论
- 作者提出指导供体分配系统下一轮迭代的关键原则,以平衡等待list死亡率与最佳移植后结局。
- 分配应基于考虑多种移植前和移植后因素且不易被支持治疗选择操纵的计算评分。
- 高危状态的等待时间应有时限并严格续期标准,重点应放在持久机械支持治疗的进一步细化。
- 无并发症的持久支持患者需要获得移植资格的路径,器官分配政策例外的同行评审对确保供体器官适当分配至关重要。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为综述,概述当前tMCS装置作为桥接策略的特征与局限,并回顾各国心脏移植分配方案。
主要发现
- 全球多数器官分配系统优先分配tMCS支持患者,存在地区差异。
- 对tMCS作为桥接策略缺乏严格标准、最佳装置选择及tMCS等待时间存在担忧。
- 装置支持后的移植结局正在演变。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Faced with a chronic donor shortage, clinicians and regulators both struggle to develop allocation systems which balance the challenges of waitlist mortality and donor availability. Most organ allocation systems across the globe have prioritized transplantation of patients supported on temporary mechanical circulatory support (tMCS) with regional variations. There are concerns that this approach might not produce optimal outcomes and is not without major drawbacks including lack of strict criteria for tMCS as bridge strategy, choice of optimal devices and wait time on tMCS. The current manuscript outlines characteristics and limitations of current devices used for tMCS as a bridging strategy. The outcomes of transplantation following device support are evolving and are highlighted as well. Lastly, the allocation schema for heart transplantation in various countries are reviewed and compared. Additionally, we propose key principles to guide changes in next iteration of donor allocation systems to balance waitlist mortality with optimal post-transplant outcomes. First, allocation should be on the basis of calculated scores which take into account a variety of pre-and post-transplant factors and cannot be easily manipulate by choice of support therapy. Next, time at high urgency statuses should be time-limited with strict criteria for renewal. Emphasis should be placed on the further refinement of durable mechanical support therapies. Patients on durable support need a pathway to qualify for transplantation in the absence of complications, and lastly, peer review of exceptions to organ allocation policy are critically important to ensure the appropriate allocation of donor organs.
引用
- Baran DA, Jaiswal A, Hennig F, et al. Temporary mechanical circulatory support: Devices, outcomes, and future directions. J Heart Lung Transplant. 2022. PMID: 35461760. doi:10.1016/j.healun.2022.03.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。