主动脉瓣开窗:保留还是修复?
该研究纳入2003至2019年接受主动脉瓣修复的患者,比较保留或修复主动脉瓣开窗对复发主动脉瓣反流或再次手术的影响。倾向评分匹配后,开窗组与无开窗组在9年生存率、再次手术累积发生率和显著反流方面相似;标准化手术方法可降低再次手术风险。
要点
- 开窗保留或修复与再次手术或显著反流复发无显著关联,前提是手术方法标准化。
- 标准化手术方法(孤立性反流双瓣环成形术、根部动脉瘤可扩张瓣下瓣环成形术加有效高度评估)降低再次手术风险。
- 开窗组中128例保留,39例修复(32例补片、6例连续缝合、1例两者兼用)。
核心结论
- 开窗无论保留或修复,在手术方法标准化的前提下,不是瓣膜修复后再次手术或显著主动脉瓣反流复发的相关因素。
研究设计与样本
- 2003年至2019年间接受主动脉瓣修复的患者被纳入研究。
- 主动脉瓣反流表型包括根部动脉瘤(修复:根部重塑+瓣环成形术)、升主动脉瘤(修复:管状主动脉替换+瓣环成形术)和孤立性反流(修复:单/双瓣环成形术)。
- 开窗根据其特征选择保留或修复。
- 798例手术患者中618例(77.4%)行瓣膜修复,其中167例存在开窗(128例保留,39例修复:32例补片、6例连续缝合、1例两者兼用)。
- 无开窗组(n=167)与开窗组(n=167)进行倾向评分匹配。
主要发现
- 9年生存率:无开窗组90.3%(7例死亡) vs 开窗组95.8%(4例死亡),P=0.94。
- 9年再次手术累积发生率:无开窗组6.7%(7例) vs 开窗组5.2%(4例)。
- 9年主动脉瓣反流≥3级:无开窗组6.4%(6例) vs 开窗组4.4%(4例);≥2级:无开窗组28.9%(28例) vs 开窗组37.1%(35例)。
- 开窗保留(P=0.55)或修复(P=0.6,6年时)与结局相似。
- 标准化手术方法降低再次手术风险(标准化前时代:风险比5.4,95%置信区间1.9-15.7,P=0.002)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: We investigated whether aortic valve fenestrations (respected or fixed) represent a factor associated with recurrent aortic insufficiency or reoperation after repair. METHODS: Between 2003 and 2019, patients who underwent aortic valve repair were included. Aortic insufficiency phenotypes were root aneurysm (repair: root remodelling + annuloplasty), ascending aorta aneurysm (repair: tubular aortic replacement + annuloplasty) and isolated regurgitation (repair: single/double annuloplasty). Fenestrations were either respected or fixed according to their features. RESULTS: A total of 618 patients (out of 798 operated on; 77.4%) had their valve repaired, with 167 cases of fenestrations (128 were respected, 39 fixed-32 with a patch, 6 with running suture and 1 with both). After conducting propensity score matching between no-fenestration (n = 167) and fenestration groups (n = 167), respectively, we noted the following: survival [90.3% (n = 7 deaths) vs 95.8% (n = 4)], cumulative incidence of reoperation [6.7% (n = 7) vs 5.2% (n = 4)], aortic insufficiency grade ≥ 3 [6.4% (n = 6) vs 4.4% (n = 4)] and grade ≥ 2 [28.9% (n = 28) vs 37.1% (n = 35)] were similar at 9 years [P = 0.94; median follow-up: 2.2, interquartile range: (0.8, 5.8)], whether fenestration was respected (P = 0.55) or fixed (P = 0.6, at 6 years). Standardization of the surgical approach (consisting of double annuloplasty in isolated regurgitation phenotype and expansible subvalvular annuloplasty with effective height assessment with remodelling repair for root aneurysm phenotype) reduced the risk of reoperation (era before standardization: hazard ratio: 5.4, 95% confidence interval: 1.9-15.7, P = 0.002). CONCLUSIONS: Fenestration, respected or fixed, is not a factor associated with reoperation or recurrence of significant aortic insufficiency after valve repair if the surgical approach is standardized.
引用
- Shraer N, Youssefi P, Monin JL, et al. Aortic valve fenestration: respect it or fix it? Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2022. PMID: 35438171. doi:10.1093/ejcts/ezac263
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。