儿童心脏手术后死亡率预测:STS先天性心脏病手术数据库分析
基于STS先天性心脏病手术数据库98 825例手术 encounter,采用贝叶斯加性回归树和lasso模型,结合新的诊断-手术类别、手术特异性危险因素及综合征构建死亡预测模型。新模型整体性能与现有STS CHSD风险模型无实质差异,但在高危手术中校准更优;对使用不同模型评估外科项目质量进行比较评估是有必要的。
要点
- 新模型整体性能与现有STS CHSD风险模型无实质差异。
- lasso与贝叶斯加性回归树模型在高风险端校准优于STS CHSD模型。
- 诊断-姑息手术变量影响<1%患者但占27%死亡,可能提升极高危手术模型性能。
核心结论
- 新模型整体性能与STS CHSD风险模型无实质差异。
- 加入手术特异性危险因素并允许诊断修正姑息手术预测风险,可能提升极高危手术的模型性能。
- 鉴于风险调整对评估医院质量的重要性,有必要使用不同模型对外科项目质量评估进行比较评估。
研究设计与样本
- 基于STS先天性心脏病手术数据库的手术 encounter 构建诊断-手术组合。
- 使用贝叶斯加性回归树和lasso模型估计手术死亡率,纳入新诊断-手术类别、手术特异性危险因素及数据库中的综合征或异常。
- 共98 825例手术 encounter(训练集69 063例;测试集29 762例),观察STS定义的手术死亡2 818例(2.85%)。
- 将新模型性能与现有STS CHSD风险模型进行比较。
主要发现
- 各模型间敏感度、特异度及真阳性与假阳性预测值的差异可忽略。
- lasso和贝叶斯加性回归树模型在高风险端的死亡率预测校准优于STS CHSD模型。
- 诊断-姑息手术变量影响<1%的患者,但占死亡27%。
- 模型区分度在高风险手术、医院手术量和医院间存在差异。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The Society of Thoracic Surgeons (STS) Congenital Heart Surgery Database (CHSD) provides risk-adjusted operative mortality rates to approximately 120 North American congenital heart centers. Optimal case-mix adjustment methods for operative mortality risk prediction in this population remain unclear. METHODS: A panel created diagnosis-procedure combinations of encounters in the CHSD. Models for operative mortality using the new diagnosis-procedure categories, procedure-specific risk factors, and syndromes or abnormalities included in the CHSD were estimated using Bayesian additive regression trees and least absolute shrinkage and selector operator (lasso) models. Performance of the new models was compared with the current STS CHSD risk model. RESULTS: Of 98 825 operative encounters (69 063 training; 29 762 testing), 2818 (2.85%) STS-defined operative mortalities were observed. Differences in sensitivity, specificity, and true and false positive predicted values were negligible across models. Calibration for mortality predictions at the higher end of risk from the lasso and Bayesian additive regression trees models was better than predictions from the STS CHSD model, likely because of the new models' inclusion of diagnosis-palliative procedure variables affecting <1% of patients overall but accounting for 27% of mortalities. Model discrimination varied across models for high-risk procedures, hospital volume, and hospitals. CONCLUSIONS: Overall performance of the new models did not differ meaningfully from the STS CHSD risk model. Adding procedure-specific risk factors and allowing diagnosis to modify predicted risk for palliative operations may augment model performance for very high-risk surgical procedures. Given the importance of risk adjustment in estimating hospital quality, a comparative assessment of surgical program quality evaluations using the different models is warranted.
引用
- Normand ST, Zelevinsky K, Nathan M, et al. Mortality Prediction After Cardiac Surgery in Children: An STS Congenital Heart Surgery Database Analysis. Ann Thorac Surg. 2022. PMID: 35122722. doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2021.11.077
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。