重新评估先天性心脏病手术中心表现:基于手术死亡率
研究比较了STS-CHSD现行O/E比值估计方法与结合诊断作为手术调节因素、其他未使用风险因素及额外置信区间构建变异的方法,在110个中心98,822例手术中,新方法O/E比值变异更大、置信区间更窄,与STS-CHSD的表现分类一致性为84%至91%,多达16%医院改变表现分类,多数改善。
要点
- 新方法O/E比值变异更大,置信区间更窄,四分位距STS-CHSD为1.11,lasso为0.80,BART为0.96。
- 与STS-CHSD表现分类一致性lasso为84%,STS Bootstrap为91%,超过70%不一致中心分类改善。
- 不一致中心手术量更小、手术死亡更少、更多患者有先天性肺异常。
核心结论
- 相对于STS-CHSD,多达16%的医院改变了表现分类,其中大多数表现改善。
- 鉴于质量报告对先天性心脏病中心的重要性,应考虑纳入额外风险因素和未解决的变异。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入110个手术中心共98,822例手术操作,采用贝叶斯加性回归树(BART)和lasso模型将手术死亡率与诊断-手术类别、手术特异性风险因素及综合征/异常关联。
- 采用自举法考虑STS-CHSD变异(STS bootstrap)和lasso置信区间,比较新方法与STS-CHSD的O/E估计、置信区间宽度四分位距及中心表现分类一致性。
主要发现
- 共2818例(2.85%)手术死亡,中心范围0.37%-10%。
- 与STS-CHSD相比,BART和lasso估计的O/E比值变异更大,置信区间更窄(置信区间四分位距:STS-CHSD=1.11,STS bootstrap=0.98,lasso=0.80,BART=0.96)。
- 表现分类与STS-CHSD的一致性范围从84%(lasso)到91%(STS Bootstrap),超过70%的不一致中心分类改善。
- 不一致中心手术量更小、手术死亡更少、治疗更多先天性肺异常患者。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The Society of Thoracic Surgeons Congenital Heart Surgery Database (STS-CHSD) provides observed-to-expected (O/E) operative mortality ratios to more than 100 congenital heart centers in North America. We compared the current approach for estimating O/E ratios to approaches incorporating information on diagnosis as moderators of procedures, other unused risk factors, and additional variation in confidence interval construction to characterize center performance. METHODS: Bayesian additive regression trees (BART) and lasso models linked operative mortality to diagnosis-procedure categories, procedure-specific risk factors, and syndromes/abnormalities. Bootstrapping accounted for variation in the STS-CHSD (STS bootstrap) and lasso CIs. We compared O/E estimates, interquartile range of CI widths, and concordance of center performance categorizations (worse-than-, as-, or better-than-expected mortality) of the new approaches to the STS-CHSD. RESULTS: In 110 surgical centers including 98,822 surgical operative encounters, there were 2818 (2.85%) operative mortalities (center range, 0.37%-10%). Compared with the STS-CHSD, BART- and lasso-estimated O/E ratios varied more and had narrower confidence intervals (interquartile range of confidence interval: STS-CHSD = 1.11, STS bootstrap = 0.98; lasso = 0.80; BART = 0.96). Concordance of performance categorization with the STS-CHSD ranged from 84% (lasso) to 91% (STS Bootstrap); more than 70% of discordant centers improved categories. Discordant centers had smaller volumes, fewer operative mortalities, and treated more patients with congenital lung abnormalities. CONCLUSIONS: Relative to the STS-CHSD, up to 16% of hospitals changed performance categories, most improving performance. Given the significance of quality reports for congenital heart centers, inclusion of additional risk factors and unaddressed variation should be considered.
引用
- Normand ST, Zelevinsky K, Nathan M, et al. Reevaluating Congenital Heart Surgery Center Performance Using Operative Mortality. Ann Thorac Surg. 2022. PMID: 35120879. doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2021.11.076
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。