加拿大慢性脊柱疼痛介入治疗循证指南
加拿大临床医生、研究者、患者伙伴及监管与资助机构代表共同制定慢性脊柱疼痛介入治疗指南。基于文献定性综合,采用美国预防服务工作组标准对每个操作给出A至D或证据不足(I)的推荐等级,并提供15条关键推荐及良好临床实践声明。
要点
- 指南针对颈椎、腰椎及骶髂关节慢性疼痛的介入操作提供循证推荐和良好临床实践声明。
- 推荐等级采用A(最强)至D(不推荐)或证据不足(I),并标注证据确定性高、中或低。
- 共识推荐要求指南专家组至少75%同意,并提出了临床适应证、疗效证据及重复操作建议频率。
核心结论
- 该指南为慢性脊柱疼痛的诊断性和治疗性介入操作提供了循证推荐和良好临床实践声明。
研究设计与样本
- 由加拿大临床医生、研究者、患者伙伴及省级医疗监管与资助机构代表组成的专家组制定。
- 对常见脊柱疼痛介入操作进行已发表文献综述,并对证据进行定性综合。
- 采用美国预防服务工作组标准对每个操作的推荐进行分级,并设定共识推荐需至少75%同意。
主要发现
- 共提供15条关键推荐。
- 指南针对源自颈椎、腰椎和骶髂关节的慢性疼痛操作给出了临床实践推荐和良好临床实践声明。
- 提出了临床适应证、疗效证据以及重复操作的推荐频率。
关键数值与推荐
- 推荐等级从A(最强水平)到D(不推荐),或为证据不足(I)。
- 证据确定性评为高、中或低。
- 共识推荐要求指南专家组至少75%同意。
临床怎么用
- 临床可依据指南推荐选择颈椎、腰椎及骶髂关节慢性疼痛的介入操作适应证。
- 可参考指南建议的操作频率和疗效证据进行重复操作决策。
- 应遵循指南中的良好临床实践声明实施诊断性和治疗性脊柱介入操作。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Summary Introduction Interventional procedures are commonly used to diagnose and treat chronic pain of spinal origin but guidance on: their indications; frequency; technical conduct; requirements for image guidance; outcome measurement; and management of complications is lacking. These guidelines were developed by a Canadian group of clinicians, researchers, patient partners and representatives from provincial healthcare regulatory and funding bodies. Methods Reviews of published literature were undertaken for commonly performed spinal procedures for pain, and the evidence was synthesised qualitatively. Evidence-based recommendations for each procedure were graded on a scale from A (strongest level) to D (not recommended), or as insufficient (I), using US Preventive Services Task Force criteria with the level of certainty rated as high, medium or low. All consensus recommendations required at least 75% agreement among the guideline panel. Good clinical practice statements were also developed. Results We provide 15 key recommendations. The guidelines provide clinical practice recommendations and good clinical practice statements for procedures targeting chronic pain originating from the cervical, lumbar spine and sacroiliac joints. Clinical indications, evidence for efficacy and suggested frequency for repeated procedures have also been proposed. Discussion These guidelines provide evidence-based recommendations and good clinical practice statements for performing diagnostic and therapeutic spinal interventions for chronic pain.
引用
- Anaesthesia:Canadian evidence‐based guidelines on spinal procedures for chronic pain
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。