文献速递术前评估与围术期医学

脑CT血管造影确定脑死亡的最佳时机:回顾性敏感性队列研究

Optimum timing of cerebral computed tomography angiography for determination of death using neurological criteria: a retrospective sensitivity cohort study
RSS 订阅 · Anaesthesia · 2026-10-21

本研究回顾性分析118例ICU患者,评估脑CT血管造影(CTA)在脑死亡判定中的敏感性。结果显示,从脑干反射消失初始体征出现至CTA检查的时间间隔显著影响敏感性:≤12小时组敏感性为67.4%,>12小时组为98.7%(P<0.001)。建议在初始体征出现至少12小时后行CTA,若结果不确定可至少12小时后重复检查。

要点

  • 脑CTA总体敏感性87.3%,假阴性多出现在脑干反射消失12小时内。
  • 延迟至12小时后检查敏感性显著提高至98.7%。
  • 建议初始体征出现至少12小时后行CTA,不确定时重复检查。

核心结论

  • 脑CTA敏感性随脑干反射消失初始体征出现后的时间间隔延长而增加。
  • 建议在初始体征出现至少12小时后行脑CTA,结果不确定时至少12小时后重复。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性敏感性队列研究,纳入118例ICU患者,均进行脑死亡判定。
  • 脑CTA采用四点评分系统确认脑循环停止,按初始体征至检查时间分组。

主要发现

  • 15/118(13%)患者脑CTA未确认脑循环停止,总体敏感性87.3%(95%CI 79.6–92.5%)。
  • 93.3%(95%CI 66.0–99.7%)的假阴性结果发生在初始体征出现12小时内。
  • 早期组(≤12小时)敏感性67.4%(95%CI 51.3–80.5%),晚期组(>12小时)98.7%(95%CI 91.8–100%),P<0.001。

关键数值与推荐

  • 脑CTA确认脑循环停止采用四点评分系统。
  • 初始体征定义为固定散大瞳孔及咳嗽、吞咽反射消失。
  • 推荐延迟脑CTA至初始体征出现至少12小时后,不确定时至少12小时后重复。

临床怎么用

  • 临床考虑脑CTA确认脑死亡时,应评估初始体征出现时间,避免12小时内检查。
  • 若早期检查结果不确定,建议至少12小时后重复CTA。

局限性

  • 回顾性研究,样本量有限,需进一步研究确认。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Summary Introduction Cerebral computed tomography angiography (CTA) is increasingly incorporated into national guidelines to confirm cerebral circulatory arrest during the determination of death using neurological criteria. However, implementation remains limited due to studies showing variable sensitivity. Clinical observations suggest the time elapsed from the onset of initial signs of brainstem areflexia, defined as the appearance of fixed and dilated pupils and loss of cough and gag reflexes, significantly influences CTA sensitivity. This study aimed to evaluate the impact of this time interval on test sensitivity. Methods We retrospectively assessed 118 intensive care unit patients undergoing determination of death using neurological criteria. Cerebral CTA was used to confirm cerebral circulatory arrest based on a four-point scoring system. Patients were categorised according to the time elapsed from the onset of initial signs of brainstem areflexia to the investigation. Results Cerebral CTA did not confirm cerebral circulatory arrest in 15/118 (13%) patients, yielding an overall sensitivity of 87.3% (95%CI 79.6–92.5%). Notably, 93.3% (95%CI 66.0–99.7%) of false-negative results occurred within 12 h of the onset of initial signs of brainstem areflexia. Patients were secondarily stratified into early (≤ 12 h) and late (> 12 h) groups, revealing a significantly higher sensitivity in the late group (67.4%, 95%CI 51.3–80.5% vs. 98.7%, 95%CI 91.8–100%, p < 0.001). Discussion The sensitivity of cerebral CTA increases with the time elapsed after the onset of initial signs of brainstem areflexia. We recommend delaying cerebral CTA until at least 12 h after the onset of initial signs of brainstem areflexia, and, in case of inconclusive results, test repetition at least 12 h later. Further work is required to confirm our findings and increase diagnostic confidence.

来源:Anaesthesia,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Anaesthesia:Optimum timing of cerebral computed tomography angiography for determination of death using neurological criteria: a retrospective sensitivity cohort study

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。