文献速递术前评估与围术期医学区域麻醉与超声

全膝关节置换术中全身、椎管内及联合麻醉的碳足迹

Carbon Footprint of General, Regional, and Combined Anesthesia for Total Knee Replacements.
PubMed 文献 · Anesthesiology · 2021-01-01

该前瞻性生命周期评估在澳大利亚墨尔本纳入29例全膝关节置换患者,比较全身麻醉、椎管内麻醉及联合麻醉的二氧化碳当量排放。三种麻醉方式碳足迹相近,全身麻醉平均14.9 kg CO2e,椎管内麻醉16.9 kg CO2e,联合麻醉18.5 kg CO2e。主要排放来源包括患者加温设备电力、一次性物品、七氟烷及可复用物品清洗灭菌。

要点

  • 三种麻醉方式碳足迹相近,椎管内麻醉并非默认低碳选择。
  • 患者加温设备电力与一次性物品是各方式共同主要排放源。
  • 选择低流量麻醉/全静脉麻醉、减少一次性塑料及氧流量可降低碳足迹。

核心结论

  • 全身麻醉、椎管内麻醉及联合麻醉在全膝关节置换中碳足迹相近,全身麻醉平均14.9 kg CO2e,椎管内麻醉16.9 kg CO2e,联合麻醉18.5 kg CO2e。
  • 椎管内麻醉不应被视为默认低碳方案,最终碳足迹取决于多项具体选择。

研究设计与样本

  • 在澳大利亚墨尔本开展的前瞻性生命周期评估,每组10例计划行膝关节置换患者。
  • 实际研究29例患者,收集麻醉物品、气体、药物及患者加温和麻醉机电力等输入数据。
  • 全身麻醉使用七氟烷或丙泊酚,采用生命周期评估软件转换为二氧化碳当量排放并进行国际建模比较。

主要发现

  • 全身麻醉平均14.9 kg CO2e(95%CI 9.7至22.5),椎管内麻醉16.9 kg CO2e(95%CI 13.2至20.5),联合麻醉18.5 kg CO2e(95%CI 12.5至27.3)。
  • 患者加温设备电力平均至少2.5 kg CO2e(占总排放20%),一次性物品在全身麻醉、椎管内麻醉和联合麻醉中分别为3.6、3.4和4.3 kg CO2e(约占总排放25%)。
  • 全身麻醉和联合麻醉组中七氟烷平均贡献4.7 kg CO2e(35%)和3.1 kg CO2e(19%)。
  • 椎管内麻醉和联合麻醉组中可复用物品清洗灭菌贡献4.5 kg CO2e(29%)和4.1 kg CO2e(24%)。
  • 椎管内麻醉碳足迹中氧气使用重要,贡献2.8 kg CO2e(18%);建模显示国家间CO2e排放变异性小于组内变异性(最小值/最大值)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 全身麻醉平均14.9 kg CO2e(95%CI 9.7至22.5),椎管内麻醉16.9 kg CO2e(95%CI 13.2至20.5),联合麻醉18.5 kg CO2e(95%CI 12.5至27.3)。
  • 患者加温设备电力平均至少2.5 kg CO2e(20%总排放);一次性物品分别为3.6(全身麻醉)、3.4(椎管内麻醉)、4.3(联合麻醉)kg CO2e(约25%总排放)。
  • 七氟烷在全身麻醉和联合麻醉中分别贡献4.7 kg CO2e(35%)和3.1 kg CO2e(19%);可复用物品清洗灭菌在椎管内麻醉和联合麻醉中分别贡献4.5 kg CO2e(29%)和4.1 kg CO2e(24%)。
  • 椎管内麻醉中氧气使用贡献2.8 kg CO2e(18%)。

临床怎么用

  • 优先选择低流量麻醉或全静脉麻醉以减少挥发性麻醉药排放。
  • 减少一次性塑料物品使用,并降低氧气流量。
  • 与工程师合作提升能源效率并使用可再生电力,以降低加温设备等电力相关排放。

局限性

  • 每组仅10例,实际共研究29例患者,样本量小。
  • 研究在澳大利亚墨尔本单中心进行,结果外推需谨慎。
  • 建模显示国家间CO2e排放变异性小于组内变异性(最小值/最大值)。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Health care itself contributes to climate change. Anesthesia is a "carbon hotspot," yet few data exist to compare anesthetic choices. The authors examined the carbon dioxide equivalent emissions associated with general anesthesia, spinal anesthesia, and combined (general and spinal anesthesia) during a total knee replacement. METHODS: A prospective life cycle assessment of 10 patients in each of three groups undergoing knee replacements was conducted in Melbourne, Australia. The authors collected input data for anesthetic items, gases, and drugs, and electricity for patient warming and anesthetic machine. Sevoflurane or propofol was used for general anesthesia. Life cycle assessment software was used to convert inputs to their carbon footprint (in kilogram carbon dioxide equivalent emissions), with modeled international comparisons. RESULTS: Twenty-nine patients were studied. The carbon dioxide equivalent emissions for general anesthesia were an average 14.9 (95% CI, 9.7 to 22.5) kg carbon dioxide equivalent emissions; spinal anesthesia, 16.9 (95% CI, 13.2 to 20.5) kg carbon dioxide equivalent; and for combined anesthesia, 18.5 (95% CI, 12.5 to 27.3) kg carbon dioxide equivalent. Major sources of carbon dioxide equivalent emissions across all approaches were as follows: electricity for the patient air warmer (average at least 2.5 kg carbon dioxide equivalent [20% total]), single-use items, 3.6 (general anesthesia), 3.4 (spinal), and 4.3 (combined) kg carbon dioxide equivalent emissions, respectively (approximately 25% total). For the general anesthesia and combined groups, sevoflurane contributed an average 4.7 kg carbon dioxide equivalent (35% total) and 3.1 kg carbon dioxide equivalent (19%), respectively. For spinal and combined, washing and sterilizing reusable items contributed 4.5 kg carbon dioxide equivalent (29% total) and 4.1 kg carbon dioxide equivalent (24%) emissions, respectively. Oxygen use was important to the spinal anesthetic carbon footprint (2.8 kg carbon dioxide equivalent, 18%). Modeling showed that intercountry carbon dioxide equivalent emission variability was less than intragroup variability (minimum/maximum). CONCLUSIONS: All anesthetic approaches had similar carbon footprints (desflurane and nitrous oxide were not used for general anesthesia). Rather than spinal being a default low carbon approach, several choices determine the final carbon footprint: using low-flow anesthesia/total intravenous anesthesia, reducing single-use plastics, reducing oxygen flows, and collaborating with engineers to augment energy efficiency/renewable electricity.

来源:Anesthesiology,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. McGain F, Sheridan N, Wickramarachchi K, et al. Carbon Footprint of General, Regional, and Combined Anesthesia for Total Knee Replacements. Anesthesiology. 2021. PMID: 34529033. doi:10.1097/ALN.0000000000003967

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。