非专科区域麻醉培训与评估:国际德尔菲共识课程研究
本研究通过两轮匿名电子德尔菲法,向全球66个国家的区域麻醉培训主任征询意见,旨在为非专科区域麻醉培训制定国际共识课程。第一轮469/586人应答(80.0%),第二轮402/469人应答(85.7%)。最终就8项核心外周及椎管内阻滞技术、17项学习目标与技能评估条目达成强共识,并明确外周阻滞每解剖区域16–20例、椎管内阻滞至少50例的操作量标准。
要点
- 强共识推荐8项核心外周及椎管内阻滞技术作为非专科培训内容。
- 外周阻滞每解剖区域操作量共识为16–20例,椎管内阻滞至少50例。
- 共识涵盖17项学习目标与技能评估条目,可用于标准化课程设计。
核心结论
- 该国际共识研究为非专科区域麻醉课程设计提供了具体信息,标准化课程的实施可通过提高培训质量和神经阻滞质量使患者获益。
研究设计与样本
- 匿名电子德尔菲研究,共两轮,发放给全球现任及近5年内曾任区域麻醉培训主任者。
- 第一轮469/586人应答(80.0%),第二轮402/469人应答(85.7%),参与者代表66个国家。
- 强共识定义为≥70%的参与者评为最高重要性(评分≥8分,10点Likert量表)。
主要发现
- 就8项核心外周及椎管内阻滞技术达成强共识。
- 就17项描述学习目标与技能评估的条目达成强共识。
- 外周阻滞操作量共识统一为每解剖区域16–20例,椎管内阻滞最低操作量为≥50例。
关键数值与推荐
- 强共识阈值:≥70%的参与者评分≥8分(10点Likert量表)。
- 外周阻滞每解剖区域操作量:16–20例。
- 椎管内阻滞最低操作量:≥50例。
临床怎么用
- 可依据本共识设计非专科区域麻醉培训课程,涵盖8项核心阻滞技术及17项学习目标与技能评估条目。
- 建议外周阻滞每解剖区域完成16–20例操作,椎管内阻滞至少完成50例,以保证培训质量。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: While there are several published recommendations and guidelines for trainees undertaking subspecialty Fellowships in regional anesthesia, a similar document describing a core regional anesthesia curriculum for non-fellowship trainees is less well defined. We aimed to produce an international consensus for the training and teaching of regional anesthesia that is applicable for the majority of worldwide anesthesiologists. METHODS: This anonymous, electronic Delphi study was conducted over two rounds and distributed to current and immediate past (within 5 years) directors of regional anesthesia training worldwide. The steering committee formulated an initial list of items covering nerve block techniques, learning objectives and skills assessment and volume of practice, relevant to a non-fellowship regional anesthesia curriculum. Participants scored these items in order of importance using a 10-point Likert scale, with free-text feedback. Strong consensus items were defined as highest importance (score ≥8) by ≥70% of all participants. RESULTS: 469 participants/586 invitations (80.0% response) scored in round 1, and 402/469 participants (85.7% response) scored in round 2. Participants represented 66 countries. Strong consensus was reached for 8 core peripheral and neuraxial blocks and 17 items describing learning objectives and skills assessment. Volume of practice for peripheral blocks was uniformly 16-20 blocks per anatomical region, while ≥50 neuraxial blocks were considered minimum. CONCLUSIONS: This international consensus study provides specific information for designing a non-fellowship regional anesthesia curriculum. Implementation of a standardized curriculum has benefits for patient care through improving quality of training and quality of nerve blocks.
引用
- Chuan A, Jeyaratnam B, Fathil S, et al. Non-Fellowship regional anesthesia training and assessment: an international Delphi study on a consensus curriculum. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2021. PMID: 34285116. doi:10.1136/rapm-2021-102934
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。