Touhy针与Quincke针在腰椎经椎间孔硬膜外阻滞中血管内注射率的比较:一项随机前瞻性试验
结果显示Tuohy针组血管内注射率显著低于Quincke针组(2.9% vs 12.7%,p=0.009),且腹侧和内侧硬膜外扩散率更高、操作时间更短。
要点
- Tuohy针血管内注射率显著低于Quincke针(2.9% vs 12.7%)。
- Tuohy针腹侧和内侧硬膜外扩散率显著高于Quincke针。
- Tuohy针操作时间短于Quincke针。
核心结论
- Tuohy针较Quincke针具有更低的血管内注射率和更高的内侧及腹侧硬膜外扩散率。
研究设计与样本
- 血管内注射通过数字减影血管造影评估。
主要发现
- 总体血管内注射发生率为7.8%。
- Tuohy针组血管内注射率显著低于Quincke针组(2.9% vs 12.7%,p=0.009)。
- Tuohy针组腹侧和内侧硬膜外扩散率分别为92.2%和95.1%,显著高于Quincke针组。
- Tuohy针组操作时间短于Quincke针组(97.4(19.3)秒 vs 117.8(31.9)秒;平均差-20.40(95%CI -34.35至-6.45),p=0.005)。
临床怎么用
- 在腰椎经椎间孔硬膜外类固醇注射中,选用22G Tuohy针可能有助于降低血管内注射风险并改善药物扩散。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Transforaminal epidural steroid injection is widely used in clinical practice to effectively deliver injectate into the ventral epidural space. Complications associated with intravascular injection such as spinal cord infarction and paraplegia can occur during transforaminal epidural steroid injection. To improve the safety of the procedure, avoidance of intravascular injection is crucial, for which appropriate needle selection is important. The primary aim of this study was to compare intravascular injection rates during transforaminal epidural steroid injection between commonly used Quincke and Tuohy needles. METHOD: Two hundred and four transforaminal epidural steroid injection cases were randomly assigned to one of two needle groups (22-gage Quincke needle or 22-gage Tuohy needle). Intravascular injection was evaluated using digital subtraction angiography. Spread of contrast medium to the ventral and medial epidural spaces was evaluated. Procedure time was compared between the two needle types. RESULTS: The overall incidence of intravascular injection was 7.8%. The rate of intravascular injection was significantly lower in the Tuohy needle group than the Quincke needle group (2.9% vs 12.7%, p=0.009). The ventral and medial epidural spread rates of the Tuohy needle group were 92.2% and 95.1%, respectively, significantly higher than those of the Quincke needle group. The procedure time was shorter in the Tuohy needle group than in the Quincke needle group (97.4 (19.3) seconds vs 117.8 (31.9) s; mean difference -20.40 (95% CI -34.35 to -6.45), p=0.005). CONCLUSIONS: In conclusion, Tuohy needles had a lower intravascular injection rate and higher medial and ventral epidural spreading rates than Quincke needles. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: KCT0002095.
引用
- Soh H, Jeong Y, Kim ED, et al. Comparison of Touhy and Quincke needles on intravascular injection rate in lumbar transforaminal epidural block: a randomized prospective trial. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2021. PMID: 34039736. doi:10.1136/rapm-2021-102504
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。