建立分娩镇痛时柔性硬膜外导管推进困难:观察性开放标签随机试验
该开放标签随机试验纳入240例请求硬膜外分娩镇痛的产妇,比较两种商用硬膜外套件中柔性导管的首次推进成功率。结果显示单端孔钢丝强化聚氨酯导管首次推进失败率为15%,显著高于多孔钢丝强化聚酰胺尼龙混合导管的0.8%(P<.0001),且导管弯曲刚度与针-导管角度存在差异。
要点
- 单端孔钢丝强化聚氨酯导管首次推进失败率15%,多孔钢丝强化聚酰胺尼龙混合导管仅0.8%。
- 导管B弯曲刚度是导管A的两倍(1.28 vs 0.64 N·mm²,P=.0038)。
- 针-导管夹角导管A较导管B更小(14.17° vs 21.83°,P=.0036)。
核心结论
- 单端孔钢丝强化聚氨酯导管的首次推进失败率高于多孔钢丝强化聚酰胺尼龙混合导管。
- 硬膜外针和导管的形态学特征差异可能对分娩硬膜外镇痛的成功建立起关键作用。
研究设计与样本
- 按两周时间间隔随机分配使用一种套件,所有患者接受柔性硬膜外导管A或B的分娩镇痛。
- 主要结局为两种套件间导管推进失败比例的差异,采用χ²检验。
主要发现
- 导管A(单端孔钢丝强化聚氨酯导管)首次尝试未推进成功者占15%(18/120),导管B(多孔钢丝强化聚酰胺尼龙混合导管)占0.8%(1/120),P<.0001。
- 导管B的弯曲刚度为导管A的两倍(1.28±0.20 vs 0.64±0.04 N·mm²,P=.0038)。
- 套件A的针与导管形成的角度较套件B更小(14.17±1.72° vs 21.83±1.33°,P=.0036),两套件角度平均差7.66°。
临床怎么用
- 选择多孔钢丝强化聚酰胺尼龙混合导管可能降低分娩镇痛时导管推进困难的风险。
- 需关注硬膜外针与导管的形态学特征对置管成功的影响。
局限性
- 研究为开放标签设计,未设盲。
- 仅比较了两种商用套件,结果外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: While flexible epidural catheters reduce the risk of paresthesia and intravascular cannulation, they may be more challenging to advance beyond the tip of a Tuohy needle. This may increase placement time, number of attempts, and possibly complications when establishing labor analgesia. This study investigated the ability to advance flexible epidural catheters through different epidural needles from 2 commonly used, commercially available, epidural kits. METHODS: We hypothesized that the multiorifice wire-reinforced polyamide nylon blend epidural catheters will have a higher rate of successful first attempt insertion than the single-end hole wire-reinforced polyurethane catheters for the establishment of labor analgesia. The primary outcome was a difference in proportions of failure to advance the epidural catheter between the 2 epidural kits and was tested by a χ2 test. Two-hundred forty epidural kits were collected (n = 120/group) for 240 laboring patients requesting epidural analgesia in this open-label clinical trial from November 2018 to September 2019. Two-week time intervals were randomized for the exclusive use of 1 of the 2 kits in this study, where all patients received labor analgesia through either the flexible epidural catheter "A" or the flexible epidural catheter "B." Engineering properties of the equipment used were then determined. RESULTS: Flexible epidural catheter "A," the single-end hole wire-reinforced polyurethane catheter, did not advance at the first attempt in 15% (n = 18 of 120) of the parturients compared to 0.8% (n = 1 of 120) of the catheter "B," the multiorifice wire-reinforced polyamide nylon blend epidural catheter (P < .0001). Twenty-five additional epidural needle manipulations were recorded in the laboring patients who received catheter "A," while 1 epidural needle manipulation was recorded in the parturients who received catheter "B" (P < .0001). Bending stiffness of the epidural catheters used from kit "B" was twice the bending stiffness of the catheters used from kit "A" (bending stiffness catheters "A" 0.64 ± 0.04 N·mm2 versus bending stiffness catheters "B" 1.28 ± 0.20 N·mm2, P = .0038), and the angle formed by the needle and the epidural catheter from kit "A" was less acute than the angle formed from kit "B" (kit "A" 14.17 ± 1.72° versus kit "B" 21.83 ± 1.33°, P = .0036), with a mean difference of 7.66° between the 2 kits' angles. CONCLUSIONS: The incidence of an inability to advance single-end hole wire-reinforced polyurethane catheter was higher compared to the use of multiorifice wire-reinforced polyamide nylon blend epidural catheter. Variation of morphological features of epidural needles and catheters may play a critical role in determining the successful establishment of labor epidural analgesia.
引用
- Pancaro C, Purtell J, LaBuda D, et al. Difficulty in Advancing Flexible Epidural Catheters When Establishing Labor Analgesia: An Observational Open-Label Randomized Trial. Anesth Analg. 2021. PMID: 33835077. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000005526
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。