气道管理模拟团队训练效果的系统综述
患者结局和临床表现相关结果不一致且方法学局限明显,多数报告态度或知识技能的研究偏向支持模拟训练但存在偏倚,当前证据强度弱。
要点
- 模拟团队训练对患者结局和临床表现的影响证据不一致且方法学局限明显。
- 多数报告态度或测试环境下知识技能的研究偏向支持模拟团队训练但易受偏倚影响。
- 当前证据强度弱,建议未来研究采用随机设计并以患者为中心结局。
核心结论
- 当前关于模拟团队训练对气道管理效果证据强度弱,难以就其对患者结局和临床表现的影响得出结论。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入以气道管理模拟团队训练为教育干预、采用任何对照、结局和设计的研究。
- 使用医学教育研究质量工具和纽卡斯尔-渥太华量表-教育版独立评估偏倚风险。
- 采用柯氏模型组织结局。
主要发现
- 4项研究报告以患者为中心的结局(柯氏4级),3项研究报告与医护人员临床表现相关的结局(柯氏3级),结果不一致且方法学局限明显。
- 报告参与者态度或感知以及测试环境下知识或技能结局(柯氏2级)的研究多数支持模拟团队训练,但易受偏倚影响。
临床怎么用
- 当前证据不足以支持将模拟团队训练作为改善气道管理患者结局的确定性措施。
- 临床可参考多数研究中参与者态度和测试环境下知识技能改善的倾向,但需认识到证据偏倚风险。
局限性
- 纳入研究存在显著方法学局限,影响结论可靠性。
- 患者结局和临床表现相关研究数量少且结果不一致。
- 报告态度或知识技能的研究易受偏倚影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Major complications associated with airway management are rare but often have serious consequences. Complications frequently result from failures in communication and teamwork. We performed a systematic review on the effect of simulation-based team training on patient outcomes, healthcare professionals' clinical performance and preparedness for airway management. We included studies with simulation-based team training in airway management as the educational intervention, using any comparator, outcome and design. Two authors independently selected articles and assessed risk of bias using the Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument and Newcastle-Ottawa Scale-Education. We screened 1248 titles and evaluated 116 full-text articles. Twenty-two studies were included. The Kirkpatrick model for evaluation of training was used to organise outcomes. Four studies reported patient-centred outcomes (Kirkpatrick level 4), and three studies' outcomes related to healthcare professionals' clinical performance (Kirkpatrick level 3). The results were ambiguous and the studies had significant methodological limitations, making it difficult to draw conclusions on the effect of simulation-based team training. To describe preparedness for airway management, we used outcomes related to participants' attitudes or perceptions and outcomes related to knowledge or skills demonstrated in a test setting (Kirkpatrick level 2). Most studies reporting these outcomes were in favour of simulation-based team training, but were prone to bias. We consider the current evidence to be weak and recommend that future research should be based on randomised study designs and patient-centred outcomes.
引用
- Nielsen RP, Nikolajsen L, Paltved C, et al. Effect of simulation-based team training in airway management: a systematic review. Anaesthesia. 2021. PMID: 33497486. doi:10.1111/anae.15375
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。