超声引导外周神经阻滞中实时注射压力与最小强度刺激联合应用的探索性观察研究
该前瞻性观察研究在28例骨科手术患者中行40次超声引导外周神经阻滞,连续测量注射压力与最小刺激强度。结果显示神经接触、神经内及神经旁位置具有不同的压力与刺激强度组合,低压力与低刺激强度可能确认神经旁位置,高压力与低刺激强度可能提示针尖位于神经内。
要点
- 神经接触时注射压力为231 mmHg(95%CI 203-259),最小刺激强度为1.70 mA(95%CI 1.38-2.02)。
- 神经内位置注射压力为188 mmHg(95%CI 152-224),最小刺激强度为0.58 mA(95%CI 0.46-0.70)。
- 神经旁位置注射压力为47 mmHg(95%CI 41-53),最小刺激强度为1.35 mA(95%CI 1.09-1.61)。
核心结论
- 注射压力与最小刺激强度的组合可能有助于在外周神经阻滞过程中判断针尖位置。
- 低注射压力与低最小刺激强度可能确认神经旁位置,高注射压力与低最小刺激强度可能提示针尖位于神经内。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性探索性观察研究,纳入28例拟行骨科手术的患者,共研究40次超声引导外周神经阻滞,获得240次观察。
- 使用计算机压力传感装置以低流速连续测量注射压力,并通过阻抗分析仪与神经刺激器在6个连续针尖位置获取刺激阈值和电阻抗。
主要发现
- 皮下、肌外膜接触、肌内、神经接触、神经内及神经旁位置均可测得特定的注射压力与最小刺激强度组合。
- 神经接触时注射压力为231 mmHg(95%CI 203-259),最小刺激强度为1.70 mA(95%CI 1.38-2.02)。
- 神经内位置注射压力为188 mmHg(95%CI 152-224),最小刺激强度为0.58 mA(95%CI 0.46-0.70)。
- 神经旁位置注射压力为47 mmHg(95%CI 41-53),最小刺激强度为1.35 mA(95%CI 1.09-1.61)。
关键数值与推荐
- 分类与回归树算法显示,最佳神经旁针尖位置可能由最低压力(<81.3 mmHg)和最小刺激强度(<1.5 mA)的 cutoffs 界定。
临床怎么用
- 在外周神经阻滞操作中,可联合监测注射压力与最小刺激强度以辅助判断针尖位置。
- 低注射压力与低最小刺激强度可能确认神经旁位置,高注射压力与低最小刺激强度应警惕针尖位于神经内。
局限性
- 本研究为探索性观察研究,旨在生成假设,结果需进一步验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Nerve damage can occur after peripheral nerve block (PNB). Ultrasound guidance does not eliminate the risk of intraneural injection or nerve injury. Combining nerve stimulation and injection pressure (IP) monitoring with ultrasound guidance has been suggested to optimize needle tip location in PNB. In this prospective observational study, we hypothesized that measured pairs of IP and minimum intensity of stimulation (MIS) might differentiate successive needle tip locations established by high-resolution ultrasound during PNB. METHODS: For this exploratory study, 240 observations for 40 ultrasound-guided PNBs were studied in 28 patients scheduled for orthopedic surgery. During the progression of the needle to the nerve observed by ultrasonography, the IP was measured continuously using a computerized pressure-sensing device with a low flow rate of solution. Stimulation thresholds and electrical impedance were obtained by an impedance analyzer coupled to the nerve stimulator at 6 successive needle positions. The median (quartile) or mean (95% confidence interval [CI]) was reported. A mixed model analysis was used, and the sample was also explored using a classification and regression tree (CART) algorithm. RESULTS: Specific combinations of IP and MIS were measured for subcutaneous, epimysium contact, intramuscular, nerve contact (231 mm Hg [203-259 mm Hg] and 1.70 mA [1.38-2.02 mA]), intraneural location (188 mm Hg [152-224 mm Hg] and 0.58 mA [0.46-0.70 mA]), and subparaneural location (47 mm Hg [41-53 mm Hg] and 1.35 mA [1.09-1.61 mA]). The CART algorithm shows that the optimal subparaneural needle tip position might be defined by the lowest pressure (<81.3 mm Hg) and MIS (<1.5 mA) cutoffs. CONCLUSIONS: Our exploratory study evaluated concepts to generate hypotheses. The combinations of IP and MIS might help the physician during a PNB procedure. A low IP and low MIS might confirm a subparaneural location, and a high IP and a low MIS might be an alert for the intraneural location of the needle tip.
引用
- Varobieff M, Choquet O, Swisser F, et al. Real-Time Injection Pressure Sensing and Minimal Intensity Stimulation Combination During Ultrasound-Guided Peripheral Nerve Blocks: An Exploratory Observational Trial. Anesth Analg. 2021. PMID: 33323786. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000005308
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。